Originally Posted by
Fluffy_Fleshwall
First let me say I play a prot pally, both in pve and pvp. But I can't see how you couldn't kill her.
I would deal with such a situation this way:
1: Change seal to Seal of Justice, it might proc when you get in range.
2: Use judgement of justice, you are now faster then she is.
3: Chains of ice -> Counter with clense, NOT with BoF.
4: Use stun and Avengers sheild as often as possible.
Those steps should put you in melee range, THEN use BoF to guarantee that you have a 12s undisturbed space where you can hammer her with all you have.
Now, these are all beautiful words, and its easy to be smart in the aftermath. But imho, adaptability in combat what separates a decent player from a good one. It is also what makes the paladin class so fun to lay.