Rate The Rogue Above You.

[Sanji]

Remember that the thread is called 'rate the rogue ABOVE you', not 'rate or comment the gear of the rogue of your personal choice from the 10 latest posters'.



Looks decent, could use the VP head and cloak though unless you're saving up for something else. Get at least the cloak, the only better option is the cloak from HC Rhyo.

6/10

Since you didn´t post an armory link, i´ll continue the thread with mine then

http://eu.battle.net/wow/en/characte...eucie/advanced

PS: Gonna enchant the MH obviously as soon as i log in

[lordrevangr]

http://eu.battle.net/wow/en/characte...1ngel/advanced

^ My rogue that dinged late December , gonna make her my main since ill get the legendaries after our main rogue

gonna lvl those pesky proffs at some point ;x

[Mohammed]

Since you didn´t post an armory link, i´ll continue the thread with mine then

http://eu.battle.net/wow/en/characte...eucie/advanced

PS: Gonna enchant the MH obviously as soon as i log in

Looks like you have done H FL, try to get the BiS cloak off Rhyolith. Other than that, you could get a very small dps gain by optimizing your reforging. Change glove enchant to 65 mastery. You may want to get some epic gems for your BiS or things that won't be replaced soon.

http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...ammad/advanced

I have access to raid finder tier chest and regular off-set shoulders, but this seems to work better.

[ymirsson]

well, shadowcraft supports your claim, 150 DPS better then the other pieces.
but you can reforge for 65 DPS
Removed reforge from Bladeshadow Wristguards
Reforged Blackfang Battleweave Gloves to -94 Expertise Rating / +94 Haste Rating
Reforged Cameo of Terrible Memories to -70 Hit Rating / +70 Mastery Rating
Reforged Shadowbinder Chestguard to -118 Crit Rating / +118 Mastery Rating
Reforged The Sleeper to -46 Crit Rating / +46 Expertise Rating
Reforged The Dreamer to -44 Mastery Rating / +44 Hit Rating

can't find anything else, further improvements are DS loot. and loot is RNG

[Mohammed]

Caveat: I typically run with DW axe, daggers for Yor'sahj. Could still probably do some reforging.

[Stuffs]

Remember that the thread is called 'rate the rogue ABOVE you', not 'rate or comment the gear of the rogue of your personal choice from the 10 latest posters'.



Looks decent, could use the VP head and cloak though unless you're saving up for something else. Get at least the cloak, the only better option is the cloak from HC Rhyo.

6/10

Using glyph of rupture, I dont know why. You should be using Glyph of SnD instead. If you are playing sub properly, rupture will not fall off, making the glyph moot. Reforging can be cleaned up somewhat based off of shadowcraft but nothing major.

[vije]

@Stuffs:
Looks nice, you could quite easily juggle a few reforges to get spellhitcap although the increase is marginal (~20dps according to shadowcraft)

Reforged Cameo of Terrible Memories to -70 Hit Rating / +70 Mastery Rating
Reforged Shadow Wing Armbands to -74 Crit Rating / +74 Mastery Rating
Reforged Blackfang Battleweave Tunic to -132 Mastery Rating / +132 Hit Rating
Reforged Blackfang Battleweave Helmet to -127 Crit Rating / +127 Hit Rating
Finished reforge optimization!

And I'd personally slap some epic gems at least to your weapons unless you're getting the legendaries soonish :]
(armory @sig)

[snookiee]

I guess I'll contribute:
http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...ostab/advanced

Here are our guild logs:
http://worldoflogs.com/guilds/73499/
The best data would be from february 2nd and 3rd, I'm Snoosnoostab.
I go sub for morchok, zon'ozz, hagara(maybe, any advice for heroic spec?), and spine. Combat for everything else. I run a ruptureless combat rotation and swap tricks with our other rogue for every fight we're both present at excluding morchok.

[Mugajak]

I give ya 7/10. 1/2 Blade Twisting (for 1/2 improved sprint, what?) and 1/3 Ruthlessness are both a bit awkward.

Uptimes for buffs/debuffs on all bosses (2/7) could have been better, even barring logging issues if you're not the one recording. Being ~~6k under your profile for a fight like Ultraxion hurts, and a lot of that comes from the SnD (and the dying, of course). Still a pity you're not first on the legendary train when you're over the stage 2'er on all the fights I looked at =(. No changes for my rogue so I'll leave this space for the next up.

[Taiina]

No armory for Mugajak so mine is in my signature.

[eirik226]

No armory for Mugajak so mine is in my signature.

All in all good I'd say!

Try to get 50 Agi gems in your cloak - And get the crafted bracer's, they are better then normal version Shadow Wing Armbands.

Other then that, reforging looks good, to my knowledge at least.

Edit: Forgot to add my rogue: eu.battle.net/wow/en/character/ravencrest/Stabjoo/advanced

Give me some ratings and/or criticism!

[Taiina]

I'm just waiting for HC wrists as it stands, not too far down the line. Epic gem wise, I moved server on friday where they are half the price so I will be filling my slots with them in the next week. They were around 5k+ on Mazrigos, now they're 2k on Sylv.

You're profile also looks great, you're missing a tinker in your gloves (isn't that most important one?) however. Also try and run HC FL for the Dreadfire cap
Over the Expertise cap too, though how i'm not quite sure as you haven't reforged into it. 0.o

9/10

[EscapeLB]

Taiina, 9/10.

Need DW weapon over The Sleeper, throw some epic gems in Dreadfire Drape.

http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...scape/advanced

[xinu]

8/10

- No 4set bonus, get t13 head asap (LFR version is a dps increase)

Other than that good, except some minor things
- 225 dps can be gained by reforging
- Emergency Descent Loop is an upgrade, altough minor, but is very easy to get

http://eu.battle.net/wow/en/characte...3%B6g/advanced

[cable]

Xinu,
You're in pvp-gear in armory so can't say anything abt pve-side. I trust you have the best possible pvp-gear you can get atm so can't improve there. Maybe slap epic gems here and there, 8/10.

http://eu.battle.net/wow/en/characte...ablè/advanced (thats spine-reforged so that part is a bit off from normal combat)

[xinu]

Ah, forgot to put on my PvE gear.

@cable
9.9/10
I'm very jelly of your daggers.
I believe the only item not BiS is normal Unchaining.
Belt and cape tinker missing, but those very rarely help with dps.

Posting my link again.
http://eu.battle.net/wow/en/characte...3%B6g/advanced

[Taiina]

Xinu,
You're in pvp-gear in armory so can't say anything abt pve-side. I trust you have the best possible pvp-gear you can get atm so can't improve there. Maybe slap epic gems here and there, 8/10.

http://eu.battle.net/wow/en/characte...ablè/advanced (thats spine-reforged so that part is a bit off from normal combat)

Not knowing what the tinkers are for belt/cape (that you're missing) I'm going to ignore them as I'm fairly sure gloves is the DPS tinker.
Other than that, I can't fault it... I'm jealous that you're so incredibly geared. =P

As you've stated, reforgings are for HC Spine, but I really can't imagine them being wrong when you're fully forged for combat so i'm going to say 10/10.

[Ashvael]

Epic gems! If you're concerned with money I'd put them in your cloak instead of items like the T2 daggers, boots, etc. which will eventually be replaced.
Else, ShadowCraft would reforge a lot of items for an amazing 2 DPS! So yeah, that part is fine.

8/10

[Drugshock]

LoL. What can I say... That's a LOT of gear!
10/10.

Here's mine: http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...ombat/advanced

[Illisar]

9/10, love the gear, hate the race sorry bro =P i just think Undead rogues are gross looking lol

http://www.wow-heroes.com/character/us/Exodar/Ishazi/

Muh rogue, be gentle, she doesn't get to raid much anymore =/