1. #1341

    Re: Rate The Rogue Above You.

    quite nice pve gear, you'll probably get kingslayer really soon
    my focus is more on arena though and i see that you havent been very busy playing pvp so i can only give you an overall of

    7/10 (+1 because you play human, human rogues are the best <3)

    my armory link:
    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...math&cn=Mintyo

    Originally Posted by Blizzard Entertainment
    No, Vanish isn’t working properly and breaks when you breathe on the rogue funny.

  2. #1342

    Re: Rate The Rogue Above You.

    6/10 your slacking with furious gear

    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...&cn=St%C3%BAff

    I was PvE'ing with one of tho 10 EU guilds but I migrated to get arena teams, my PvE gear is all 264

  3. #1343

    Re: Rate The Rogue Above You.

    Quote Originally Posted by screwzx
    6/10 your slacking with furious gear

    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...&cn=St%C3%BAff

    I was PvE'ing with one of tho 10 EU guilds but I migrated to get arena teams, my PvE gear is all 264
    Dunno much about PvP but I really want your dagger :P

    And yeah, I had a faction change.
    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...rhorn&n=Secord

  4. #1344

    Re: Rate The Rogue Above You.

    I have no clue why ur gemming arp as a assassination rogue, Idk if u were combat before, but i suggest u gemming AP/haste.

    http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...Iron&cn=Cangri

    My next upgrade will be helm, should have it this week. Thinking about droping some of my haste gems for more arp.


  5. #1345

    Re: Rate The Rogue Above You.

    It's allright - I don't like how low your AP/crit is and the unecessary expertise though.

    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...mane&cn=Connar

    What do you think?

    As everyone say, "lolol boost ur hit+exp and u'll see a huge dps increase"
    My answer will probably be.....: No, not true. How important do you really think the expertise it? It is not. I can easily pull 10-11k DPS on a tank and spank/melee friendly fight.

    So don't judge me by my expertise, so what do you think?

  6. #1346

    Re: Rate The Rogue Above You.

    Quote Originally Posted by Olesaue
    It's allright - I don't like how low your AP/crit is and the unecessary expertise though.

    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...mane&cn=Connar

    What do you think?

    As everyone say, "lolol boost ur hit+exp and u'll see a huge dps increase"
    My answer will probably be.....: No, not true. How important do you really think the expertise it? It is not. I can easily pull 10-11k DPS on a tank and spank/melee friendly fight.

    So don't judge me by my expertise, so what do you think?
    I think you need more Exp & Hit

  7. #1347

    Re: Rate The Rogue Above You.

    poster above didnt leave armory link

    my armory is in sig
    After earning enough Combo Points, the Rogue's next finisher will include fries and a drink.

  8. #1348
    Stood in the Fire Mookes's Avatar
    10+ Year Old Account
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Location
    Seattle
    Posts
    397

    Re: Rate The Rogue Above You.

    Quote Originally Posted by Olesaue
    It's allright - I don't like how low your AP/crit is and the unecessary expertise though.

    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...mane&cn=Connar

    What do you think?

    As everyone say, "lolol boost ur hit+exp and u'll see a huge dps increase"
    My answer will probably be.....: No, not true. How important do you really think the expertise it? It is not. I can easily pull 10-11k DPS on a tank and spank/melee friendly fight.

    So don't judge me by my expertise, so what do you think?
    Lol, do you think you are so pro that expertise and hit don't a apply to you? No. Link a WWS with 11k DPS and i won't judge you. To answer your question, hit and expertise are the two most important stats a rogue can have.



    http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...anis&cn=Klaine

    *NOT MY ARMORY, KEEPING THE THREAD ALIVE*
    ^^^^^^RATE PERSON ABOVE ME^^^^^^^
    ^^^^^^RATE PERSON ABOVE ME^^^^^^^

    "Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity..and I'm not sure about the the universe." -Albert Einstein


    ----------------CLICK SIGNATURE FOR ARMORY----------------

  9. #1349

  10. #1350

    Re: Rate The Rogue Above You.

    looks good Faeruun. 10/10

    http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...ane&cn=Orodoth

    Work in progress. I know i still have some ArP on my gear where I made a recent change over from combat >_< (but hey, 8.5k dps in a 25 man is still 8.5k!)

  11. #1351

    Re: Rate The Rogue Above You.

    Currently my rogue is in a pvp gear set up i put together last week sorry trying to get into arenas a little more to build my skill. I'll be posting about Shogos rogue above me. i am hakuran of us-ravenholdt

    http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...ldt&cn=Hakuran

    I give shogo an 5/10. Not to bad for an new rogue i guess getting into icc. I dont know if you study the spread sheet as i do but i read that once you have more i264 pieces and more 251 pieces that you should not be gemming haste. I am guessing you have about an 5.3 5,4k gs. So one thing i knocked you down major points for is not havig the bis mutilation spec trinket atm you are using the tri badge trinket that once you use it you have 1k ap for a few seconds and with a cd of 2 minutes. Which honestly is destorying your dps. Also i rated you an 6 because your haste rating even when you gemmed it is way to low which if you had the bis war token would give you 150 haste off bat. i also seen in you chest piece you have an 10agi 10 crit gemm for unknown reason i dont know why but is lowering your dps. also your boot enchant is not the beast if its not the nitro boots for getting to bosses ur dps will take a fall. I also seen you gemmed arp idk if you were an combat rogue but mut should have it unless its on your 264 bracers from icc saurfang it shouldnt be a stat we look for as mut its bad

    Also you dps spec is currently not optimized for maxium damage out put. Seeing that you dont have the max points in lighting reflexes is an other problem to why i find it unreal for u to be pulling off 8k dps. also your assiantion build need to be redone as well i dont see fleet footed in your spec. i also seen that your daggers spec is not maxed out liek it should be and that you have wasted two points in oppurtunity which mutilate is less the 8% of any good mut rogues rtation fix those problems and you should do fine

  12. #1352

    Re: Rate The Rogue Above You.

    Quote Originally Posted by shogo238
    looks good Faeruun. 10/10
    Quote Originally Posted by Faeruun
    I'm sorry but please don't tell Faeruun that he's 10/10 when he's not.

    Well below both exp and hit caps, low amount of arpen but still gemming for it. Unless you have a arpen trinket, you really should not be gemming arpen. I'd say consult a spreadsheet a little more. It would probably say use Rigid King's Amber in your yellow slots and a couple of expertise gems in red slots.

    Nice gear, for sure, but gemming is not good. Hit your caps and then worry about your other stats.

    Edit: I would like to point out that you have an awesome amount of haste. But you'll probably have to replace your 20ap/10haste gems with 20ap/10hit or maybe even 20hit. And all of your agi/crit gems should DEFINITELY be ap/hit or all hit

  13. #1353

    Re: Rate The Rogue Above You.

    I must admitt with the level of repeated information on PvE mutilate and Combat it would be so so so VERY HARD to NOT gear a rogue correctly, lol.

  14. #1354

    Re: Rate The Rogue Above You.

    hakuran, the main problem i see is that you have pushed past the standard expertise cap, so you have a wasted gem slot that can take another gem [your gloves or ring]

    if i remember, the exp cap without the combat talent is 26 [214 rating] you're at 30, [256 rating]. and as you know, get your engineering up :3

    This is mine.

    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...&gn=Safe+Haven

    i'am aware of the abysmal expertise. getting expertise gems till i manage to get gear with exp on it [should i replace my +20ap/haste gems with the exp gems?]

  15. #1355

    Re: Rate The Rogue Above You.

    Quote Originally Posted by Hakuran
    i find it unreal for u to be pulling off 8k dps.
    Not trying to start some @#$% here but I'll gladly screen shot the recount when I go back into ICC 25 this week if you doubt me.

  16. #1356

    Re: Rate The Rogue Above You.

    Quote Originally Posted by Tenjen
    hakuran, the main problem i see is that you have pushed past the standard expertise cap, so you have a wasted gem slot that can take another gem [your gloves or ring]

    if i remember, the exp cap without the combat talent is 26 [214 rating] you're at 30, [256 rating]. and as you know, get your engineering up :3

    This is mine.

    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...&gn=Safe+Haven

    i'am aware of the abysmal expertise. getting expertise gems till i manage to get gear with exp on it [should i replace my +20ap/haste gems with the exp gems?]
    as you said, biggest problem is the expertise, otherwise, the 10 stats gem could be used in a better slot for a socket bonus, Herbalism aint optimal for Pve works if you pvp tho, other than that seems okay, considered buying the leatherworking boots from icc? also your hitrating can easily be lowerd by removeing your Mark of Supermacy and replaceing it with vengance of the forsaken or the alliance version of it, dont know it but yeah you get the point, should boost your expertise but bout 10 (the normal one),

    Heres mine http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...cn=Dj%C3%A4vul
    aware of the 1 missing gem for expertise cap, and leave my First build alone as its an fail build ive been playing with in arena a bit xD

  17. #1357

    Re: Rate The Rogue Above You.

    Djävul, All looks good but i have 1 question, why did you buy Cat burglar's grips with badges when clearly the bigger upgrade for your spec and gear choice would be the 2 set, acheiveable with the t10 gloves instead?

    Anyways, here's me
    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...ear&cn=Drifted
    be gentle

  18. #1358

    Re: Rate The Rogue Above You.

    Awesome gear but off-hand looks bad with BiS Main-hand :P

    Here's mine!
    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...alls&cn=Jingoo

  19. #1359

    Re: Rate The Rogue Above You.

    Quote Originally Posted by Jingoo
    Awesome gear but off-hand looks bad with BiS Main-hand :P

    Here's mine!
    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...alls&cn=Jingoo
    Nothing much to complain about, the nightmare tear would have been better in the helm.

    ill give you a 8/10, shouldn't have bought that cloak for mutilate, and get 2 piece t10 asap.

    My Armory is in my Sig, got skipped over last time!!!
    After earning enough Combo Points, the Rogue's next finisher will include fries and a drink.

  20. #1360

    Re: Rate The Rogue Above You.

    Quote Originally Posted by Paranoia
    Nothing much to complain about, the nightmare tear would have been better in the helm.

    ill give you a 8/10, shouldn't have bought that cloak for mutilate, and get 2 piece t10 asap.

    My Armory is in my Sig, got skipped over last time!!!
    tbh your gear is beautiful. grats on the recent lucky acquisition of your 4piece t10 in voa25 ;P

    seems that you've put yourself near your crit cap with a feral druid in your group (though I didn't do the exact math so you MIGHT be a little over, you may want to check). expertise is a tad high but nothing to cry about. replace your OH with the dreamwalker25 one if you get the chance, so you can get rid of some arp. not much else to say tbh. Smart gemming, smart professions.
    9.98/10

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •