Rate The Rogue Above You.

[Reconsider]

Cant Remember the need for the Meta, but isnt it 3 Reds. In that case i would change the gem in your ring.+10 Agi is not a good enough socket bonus to socket for. I would change that to a Delicate.
Otherwise it seems good.

Mine is http://eu.battle.net/wow/en/character/kor'gall/moonblood/simple
Pants arent enchanted and not gemmed really. Planning on getting the usual Leg Enchant, and a 20agi-20Haste gem in the last slot on Legs.
Glove enchant simmed out to be a 1dps loss compared to the mastery one. And as much as i like to top dps, 1 dps isnt gonna make or break it at this point. And its LFR stuff, so xD

You stated your major issues. Fix your legs, and 65mastery to gloves. Click signature for my armory.

[Resentful]

Looks good to me 9/10, Removed 1 point because your tabard doesn't match!

[vije]

Looks good to me 9/10, Removed 1 point because your tabard doesn't match!

9/10, because I'm jealous of your mounts and mh glaive. very jealous. armory in sig

[Stuffs]

9/10, because I'm jealous of your mounts and mh glaive. very jealous. armory in sig

Your transmog set makes me think of aquaman

Im going to assume you're MS Assass since you're reforged heavily for mastery
In which case, you might want to look at making your OS combat, since mastery is so poor for Sub. Shadowcraft is indicating without changing any reforging, Sub is a bit over a 850 DPS loss over combat(though there is the whole Morchok thing, but on the inverse you aren't specced for Enveloping Shadows so I'm not sure what to interpret for that bit. I'm probably over reading with a lack of info at this point)

Personally I prefer gearing hard combat, OS sub, but we all have our preferences.

Reforging and gemming are right.

[Coldkil]

A lot of time passed since my last post here link in sig :P

[tigojones]

Obviously, get the new gear enchanted. Aside from that, I'm not familiar enough with my rogue to really critique others.


Mine again, been a while since I last had him posted, and he's come a long way. Used to be an alt I didn't really worry about to my new main. Now to see how I'm doing.
http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...sneak/advanced

[Splitmind]

7/10 ^ hunters are the best class imo

[Splosion]

I'll use this as my rate, since the guy above didn't post anything

Obviously, get the new gear enchanted. Aside from that, I'm not familiar enough with my rogue to really critique others.


Mine again, been a while since I last had him posted, and he's come a long way. Used to be an alt I didn't really worry about to my new main. Now to see how I'm doing.
http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...sneak/advanced

I might be wrong, but isn't matching socket bonuses a good thing for combat rogues? Shadowcraft may have told you otherwise ofc. You could put Assassin's step on your boots + major agility on your bracers. I assume you're not using peerless on the chest because of where it's from.

Spec and glyphs are fine, 9/10 (because of enchants)

My link is in my signature, enchants for legs + stage 1 offhand coming shortly (shadowcraft is telling me the MH is inferior to what I have)

[Diciple]

^^
as you mentioned youre missing leg enchant and stage 1 daggers! srsly the stage 1 dagger are great for combat/sub triple secondary stats compared to your mainhand.

http://eu.battle.net/wow/en/characte...ciple/advanced

[Viradiance]

^^
as you mentioned youre missing leg enchant and stage 1 daggers! srsly the stage 1 dagger are great for combat/sub triple secondary stats compared to your mainhand.

http://eu.battle.net/wow/en/characte...ciple/advanced

Only one thing I can observe that seems odd...

Did you drop the T12 4-peice for T13's 2-piece? That seems really odd to me-- especially if you had 391 T12 pants and Gloves.

But everything else looks lovely.

http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...iridian/simple
(Ignore my shitty chest enchant-- I was broke and I guess I just never got around to fixing it. Also, keep in mind my guild is a Semicasual bonanza. Mostly an RP guild.)

My link is in my signature, enchants for legs + stage 1 offhand coming shortly (shadowcraft is telling me the MH is inferior to what I have)

Also, I'm pretty sure that Shadowcraft is just a -bit- out-of-date on the Daggers. I don't think they've added in Weighted Blades, because it marked them as a downgrade to even the 365 Horseman's Blade for me. I don't think it takes into account the proc, the value increase for Mastery, and the weighted blades. I would just assume them to be greater then all gear until possibly Heroic Dragon Soul.

Edit: Yeah, it's definitely still WiP concerning the daggers. It rates them as being lower then Sun Strike (reg) for me.

[unhooman]

After doing DS for a couple weeks, my dps seems a bit lower than it should be with my gear. Can anyone look me over?

http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...eijin/advanced

[Stuffs]

After doing DS for a couple weeks, my dps seems a bit lower than it should be with my gear. Can anyone look me over?

http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...eijin/advanced

-Why are you using the sword instead of Fear. It hits just as hard due to the baked in buff, more agi, blah blah
-Spec is fine
-Glyphs are fine
-You can clean up reforging somewhat. Consult shadowcraft for the details

[Sesethi]

10/10, ur gear makes me envy.
O hai guise, wats goin on
http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...uriel/advanced

[Deleted]

Hey, fairly newish rogue alt - maybe main (do enjoy the old rogues - only melee class I do!).

Not really good enough to pass remarks on others yet so just cheekily posting my link for a rating :P

eu.battle.net/wow/en/character/hellfire/Bejal/simple

[kilj]

^^ LOOKS GOOD your on the right track, 9/10. But after looking at your gear I'd stick with combat till you can push 2k+ mastery.

Its been awhile so time to throw my rogue on the table and yes I still use 50 haste to gloves over 65 mastery.

http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...%C3%B8n/simple

[RogueOlf]

I envy your progress...and looks good overall. How are the daggers treating you in combat? I believe I will off-spec there. I cannot say good-bye to assassination though.

us.battle.net/wow/en/character/silvermoon/Olf/advanced

[kilj]

The daggers in my mind are BiS even for combat because of the buff to sinister strike and revealing strike. Only way I wouldn't use them is if I had a heroic MH from HDS but my guild isn't on that yet .

Rate 10/10 you seem to know what your are doing I still dont know about the whole 65 crit vs 22 agi to cloak

[tigojones]

I'll use this as my rate, since the guy above didn't post anything



I might be wrong, but isn't matching socket bonuses a good thing for combat rogues? Shadowcraft may have told you otherwise ofc. You could put Assassin's step on your boots + major agility on your bracers. I assume you're not using peerless on the chest because of where it's from.

Spec and glyphs are fine, 9/10 (because of enchants)

My link is in my signature, enchants for legs + stage 1 offhand coming shortly (shadowcraft is telling me the MH is inferior to what I have)

I've been hearing conflicting reports on whether to match or not, mostly around whether losing 10agi would be worth the +20 hit/haste. I went for +15 stats rather than +20 simply because at the time +20 was going for a ridiculous price (both as a scroll and for the mats). +20 will definitely go on my tier piece (whenever I get it).

I'll punch in the gems/enchants into shadowcraft and see what comes up.

Thanks.

[Deleted]

As tigojones was 'judged' already above, and I couldn't add something new, only the request to 'judge' my rogue.
Currently on 4/8 normal, pushing around 30k on boss 5 in the last few tries (no don't start the boss 5 is easy.. -> I <- know ;-) )

Should I pull more, or am I on the right track?

(Link in sig)

Thanks in advance

[Reconsider]

30k isnt bad for your current gear. Crit to cape, but it seems a lot of people are fighting that now.

Link in signature.