As i see it (and yes i didn't read the whole post) is that the hit was a dead stat for the warrior hence the Trinket from thorim was an upgrade. A real one. And really i can't see why your whining, Youre a rank below him, the trinket will surely drop again. And really do you think that a grim toll will make it or brake it for your guild?
Someones who's loothorny coming through!! Tooot Toot.