Which Prot ToC shoulders should I go with?

[Saverem]

http://www.wowhead.com/?compare=48460;47699;47514&weights=Warrior%20-%20Protection%20(Tanking);Warrior%20-%20Protection%20(Tanking);22:42:45:117:21:46:43:20:119:41:96:114:77:103:123;22:42:45:117:2 1:46:43:20:119:41:96:114:77:103:123;100:66:59:58:53:50:22:17:7:7:5:5:3:3:-100;100:66:59:58:53:50:22:17:7:7:5:5:3:3:-100


Basically, the one on far right is the one I have.

I'm stuck between the 45 emblem of triumph one from Dalaran or the 30 EoT one from the ToC 10m.

They both have their pros and cons. My guild hasn't started raiding ToC yet, so all my emblems are from dailies and VoA's new boss. This means that the 45 emblem one pretty much takes a week's worth of dailies over the other one, but the stats on it are a lot better.

The other one on the other hand is part of a set which means I get set bonus.

Sooo, I don't know. What do you guys suggest?

[erwin121]

Kinda depends on your other gear, but i think the ring would be your best choice. At least that is what i took, since its the second best ring in game imo. And i only have 4 pieces of tier8 and the 4 piece set bonus rocks imo.

[Phyta]

First off he didnt link a ring whatsoever so im not sure where your getting that from. Secondly, you need to go for http://www.wowhead.com/?item=47699 , higher ilvl, and alot more avoidance on it, the stats scream "PLATE TANK" vs something with exp on it. Exp is good sure, but im already over 31 exp when only needing 26 just from gear alone. Dont need more of it.

[Eraser]

Just because he didn't link the ring doesn't mean he's wrong, and also just because you're so "awesome" that you have 31 exp doesn't mean other people have the same option to gear.

http://www.tankingtips.com/2009/08/3...ph-pick-order/

Thankfully, someone has done the comparisons already for whats the best gear updgrades from EoT, and yes it's the ring who's the clear winner....