1. #1121

    Re: Rate the Paladin Tank above you!

    http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...n&gn=Disavowed

    was thinking about dual spec for tanking heroics - reckoning and SoCom, but how do i look?

    (pala is an alt but ive been getting him geared to be my new main Christan-Darkspear was my main / kind of is still i guess, idk)
    Still I cry, tears like pouring rain, Innocent is my lurid pain.

  2. #1122
    High Overlord
    Join Date
    Feb 2010
    Location
    Sweden
    Posts
    120

    Re: Rate the Paladin Tank above you!

    Quote Originally Posted by Christan
    http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...n&gn=Disavowed

    was thinking about dual spec for tanking heroics - reckoning and SoCom, but how do i look?

    (pala is an alt but ive been getting him geared to be my new main Christan-Darkspear was my main / kind of is still i guess, idk)

    Specc: Put the points in conviction that is a weak treath specc to Persuit of Justice(let's you have 22 stamina on boots) and 1 point in SoC aoe treath seal.

    Enchants: Replace following: Shoulder ench to 30 stamina, Back to 225 armor, Chest to 275 hp, Hands to 18 stam, feets to 22 stam, shield to 18 stam. If you go under 540 def keep one def enchant. Mongoose on Wep

    Gems: I wouldn't go for that many weak socket bonuses as you do, tho your choice. Never socket 10 all stats as a protpala.

    That's about it 5/10


    Armory link in sig


  3. #1123

    Re: Rate the Paladin Tank above you!

    Quote Originally Posted by Banan

    Specc: Put the points in conviction that is a weak treath specc to Persuit of Justice(let's you have 22 stamina on boots) and 1 point in SoC aoe treath seal.

    Enchants: Replace following: Shoulder ench to 30 stamina, Back to 225 armor, Chest to 275 hp, Hands to 18 stam, feets to 22 stam, shield to 18 stam. If you go under 540 def keep one def enchant. Mongoose on Wep

    Gems: I wouldn't go for that many weak socket bonuses as you do, tho your choice. Never socket 10 all stats as a protpala.

    That's about it 5/10


    Armory link in sig

    8/10, both the spec and the glyphs are generally fine (even tho I'd change the Hammer of the Righteousness for the taunt one, since you already have the Seal of Command specced for aoe tanking), it's clear that you are a stam enthusiast from the socketing, wich i don't full agree on but respect as it's a matter of personal taste, still the enchant on the gloves should be agi anyways.

    I'll link my profile again since the earlier post got ignored
    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...kull&cn=Tutela

  4. #1124
    High Overlord
    Join Date
    Feb 2010
    Location
    Sweden
    Posts
    120

    Re: Rate the Paladin Tank above you!

    Quote Originally Posted by Tutela
    8/10, both the spec and the glyphs are generally fine (even tho I'd change the Hammer of the Righteousness for the taunt one, since you already have the Seal of Command specced for aoe tanking), it's clear that you are a stam enthusiast from the socketing, wich i don't full agree on but respect as it's a matter of personal taste, still the enchant on the gloves should be agi anyways.

    I'll link my profile again since the earlier post got ignored
    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...kull&cn=Tutela
    Give me a reason why change to 20 agi? and 275hp on chest is still way better than 10 all stats. 10str 10 agi verses 175 hp. Ofc I'm a stamina enthusiast since I don't lack defense such as you do. You would be that aswell If you had more defense gear and were not forced to gem/enchant defense

  5. #1125

    Re: Rate the Paladin Tank above you!

    Quote Originally Posted by Banan
    Give me a reason why change to 20 agi? and 275hp on chest is still way better than 10 all stats. 10str 10 agi verses 175 hp. Ofc I'm a stamina enthusiast since I don't lack defense such as you do. You would be that aswell If you had more defense gear and were not forced to gem/enchant defense
    Perhaps it's a reason of personal taste again, i like having some extra avoidance from slots where the enchant that gives stamina isn't that life-changing, I had no mean to be offensive in any way tho
    And for the defense thingy, you're most certainly right, but I did some choices in gearing (say, crafted pieces + Tier Chest) that led me to be surprisingly undercapped, and that's something I don't like myself in first place.

  6. #1126

    Re: Rate the Paladin Tank above you!

    nothing but replies above, so I will just post my pally

    http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...alaran&cn=Olus

  7. #1127

    Re: Rate the Paladin Tank above you!

    Quote Originally Posted by Olus
    nothing but replies above, so I will just post my pally

    http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...alaran&cn=Olus
    Can't find any flaw at all. Only thing would be that 18 stam on gloves possibly would yield more EH, but as I haven't done the math myself I can't say for sure.
    SoC is a matter of taste so I won't comment on not speccing that.

    For the poster below, my reasoning for using both HotR glyph and SoC is to make heroic tanking easier and go faster due to more damage. Other than that, nitpick on anything you want.
    Quote Originally Posted by Rugz
    Holes means you have less of a food to plate ratio, you can get more net weight of pancakes into the same volume and area as you could with waffles. Therefore pancakes win.

  8. #1128

    Re: Rate the Paladin Tank above you!

    Quote Originally Posted by Olus
    nothing but replies above, so I will just post my pally

    http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...alaran&cn=Olus
    9/10 Your gear is really good.

    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...cn=magnathorax


  9. #1129

    Re: Rate the Paladin Tank above you!

    Quote Originally Posted by Magnathorax
    7/10 Abit low lvl gear otherwise good enchants (Considering your close to def cap) I would change out the defence gems since your slightly over the cap and can live without them.
    Skip bladeward there is better enchants Moongoose for example.
    You might want to consider Armsman on gloves, gives a little extra tps.
    And i would only gem one red and rest stamina since thats all you need to activate the meta gem.


    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...er&cn=Pappadin

  10. #1130

    Re: Rate the Paladin Tank above you!

    Not armor happy enough. Still, quite good gear, altho pants are the slot that gets out for 4/5 t10 (pillars of might GO!)
    Titanium Plating in t10 content, is, to my sorryness, a waste. won't do any good.
    also, blade ward/blood drain over mongoose.
    8.5/10
    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...otem&cn=Aureon

  11. #1131

    Re: Rate the Paladin Tank above you!

    Quote Originally Posted by Aureon
    Not armor happy enough. Still, quite good gear, altho pants are the slot that gets out for 4/5 t10 (pillars of might GO!)
    Titanium Plating in t10 content, is, to my sorryness, a waste. won't do any good.
    also, blade ward/blood drain over mongoose.
    8.5/10
    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...otem&cn=Aureon
    I would prefer mongoose over blood drain tbh, and I would never go for the titanium spike on shield, total waste, but overall the gear is quite nice. Geemed pretty good execpt shoulders, I know u want the 9 stamina but 15 def rating is really a waste in icc content.
    Overall 9/10

    Armory link
    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...ider&cn=Xoriak

  12. #1132

    Re: Rate the Paladin Tank above you!

    Quote Originally Posted by Xoriak
    I would prefer mongoose over blood drain tbh, and I would never go for the titanium spike on shield, total waste, but overall the gear is quite nice. Geemed pretty good execpt shoulders, I know u want the 9 stamina but 15 def rating is really a waste in icc content.
    Overall 9/10

    Armory link
    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...ider&cn=Xoriak
    Very nice gear, you specced conviction over SoC, Vin and PoJ but i think you have your reasons for it.. warr in raid with their shout etc

    9/10 keep it up

    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...Akir&cn=Methox

  13. #1133

    Re: Rate the Paladin Tank above you!

    Quote Originally Posted by Methox
    Very nice gear, you specced conviction over SoC, Vin and PoJ but i think you have your reasons for it.. warr in raid with their shout etc

    9/10 keep it up

    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...Akir&cn=Methox
    9/10...Just cause we still have more space to improvements...

    Just to put me in your wised judgements.
    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...s&cn=Lanncelot

  14. #1134

    Re: Rate the Paladin Tank above you!

    Get rid of all the non "+30 Stam" gems you have. The socket bonuses aren't netting you more hp with those gems. Replace them. Put a "10 AGI-15 Stam" gem in your head slot, it's better than the defense one.

    Replace your defense enchants with EH enchants. Armor on cloak, 275hp on chest, 18 Stam on gloves, 18 stam on shield.

    Put on mongoose on your weapon, you have PoJ you don't need the weapon chain.

    Take 2 points in divinity and put them in Divine Guardian

    Take 1 point out of benediction and put it into "improved judgements"

    If you want SoComm for trash, take the point out of conviction for it.

    http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...n=Vaudevillian
    (This signature was removed for violation of the Avatar & Signature Guidelines)

  15. #1135

    Re: Rate the Paladin Tank above you!

    8/10, though I'm tempted to smack you around a bit for having 2x brewfest


    http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...enas&n=sunetra

    I know that the weapon chain sucks. I got the cleaver as a weapon to use in old school content for farming and tossed a chain on it (for the hit rating). I just keep forgetting to toss mongoose on it

  16. #1136

    Re: Rate the Paladin Tank above you!


  17. #1137

    Re: Rate the Paladin Tank above you!

    Quote Originally Posted by shoju
    8/10, though I'm tempted to smack you around a bit for having 2x brewfest


    http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...enas&n=sunetra

    I know that the weapon chain sucks. I got the cleaver as a weapon to use in old school content for farming and tossed a chain on it (for the hit rating). I just keep forgetting to toss mongoose on it
    Because stacking stamina is soooooo stupid.


    Spec & Glyphs
    Go

    Gear
    Go


    Replace that weapon chain when you can.

    9/10

    Spec & Glyphs
    Spec out of Seals of the Pure. Use those points to pick up Vindication and Crusade. Vindication is free improved demo shout, if you have a reliable warrior or bear then put those points into conviction. Crusade is better tps/dps in every raid except Ulduar. You aren't raiding only Ulduar are you?
    Only spec into 1/2 spiritual attunement. Use that extra point to either pick up another point of conviction or Seal of command, I strongly recommend SoC for more AoE threat, more importantly AoE threat with no ramp up time.
    7/10

    Gear
    0/10
    You are alliance and I hate the level 60 alliance paladin set. You also should enchant them. ^_^


    Link is in sig.


  18. #1138

    Re: Rate the Paladin Tank above you!

    I feel like there is an extremely large amounts of paladins who post in these type of threads who miss the "rate the paladin above you" part and only see "get rated by the 3 or 4 paladins who bother here"


    http://www.wowarmory.com/character-sheet.xml?r=Dethecus&n=Solandrys

  19. #1139

    Re: Rate the Paladin Tank above you!

    Quote Originally Posted by luthe
    I feel like there is an extremely large amounts of paladins who post in these type of threads who miss the "rate the paladin above you" part and only see "get rated by the 3 or 4 paladins who bother here"
    Think I once spent part of a page trolling a few for that.

  20. #1140

    Re: Rate the Paladin Tank above you!

    Quote Originally Posted by luthe
    I feel like there is an extremely large amounts of paladins who post in these type of threads who miss the "rate the paladin above you" part and only see "get rated by the 3 or 4 paladins who bother here"
    It also feels a bit like I'm repeating myself.

    DS/DG > Reckoning. SotP sucks, 1 or 2 imp. judgement doesn't matter, vindication, PoJ and Crusade are awesome and gem stam everywhere where the bonus isn't good, agi/stam to activate meta.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •