I searched and I searched, but this thread seems to be gone. Therefore I created a new one. Basically, this is a gathering place for your biggest WTF-moments in instances, raids, arenas and, well, biggest WTF-moments in the game.
I will start by a little story of my own. Earlier today, you see, I was in a group to do Sartharion +3 drakes, zerg method. Having quite some bad experiences with earlier groups, I hoped this was a good one. I asked if everyone was able to do at least 4.5k dps, asked those who knew that they couldn't to leave, and inquired if someone was downright stupid. Noone left and people seemed, well, at least half-smart, so off we go. Tank had quite low hp and healer's gear wasn't the best imagineable, but I figured they could manage since it's a pretty easy fight on the tanking/healing part.
So, we get inside, buff up, have a little discussion about which paladin buffs what, and off we go to clear trash. Once it's dead I think "so far so good". Some people are of course quite low on the dps but I figured they just slacked or did /follow. Therefore, we get into position and do a ready check.
It's about this time I start to inspect people a little closer and see that, well, our elemental shaman has full healing gear. Not just the odd ring or neck but basically 0 hit rating. I thought "Oh Geez, another one thinking they can dps in healing gear...". I've seen this before, a boomkin running in with two mp5 trinkets and doing a whooping 1.9k dps. However, he does ask me to give him a chance and as the willing soul I am, I do.
Tank pulls. Sartharion is facing the raid. I think "WTF??" and tries my best to tell him to turn Sarth away. Too late, raid gets flame breath'd. Damn. Well, luckily noone died but since some people were on very low hp it didn't take them long to get hit by lava strike or an add, resulting in a major case of deadness. Then the drake comes down, tank dies (unsurprisingly) and we wipe. Afterwards I decide to check recount to see if we even have a chance. Well, the elemental shaman in full healing gear actually does pretty good for himself, far from enough for a Sartharion zerg but if I remember correctly he did 3.4k dps. What really surprised me was the boomkin in the group that did a whooping 2k dps. Yup.
I link the dps, and the boomkin gives me the best reaction I've ever seen in the game.
"WTF!"
"I CRIT ALL THE TIME"
Priceless. Seeing as noone, not even if you have 0% crit chance, should be able to do 2k dps only, specially not with that gear (doable for 25-man Ulduar), I check him a little more closely. What spells did he cast? Starfire. Nothing but Starfire. I think I've found the source... Needless to say I left the group presto. And by this time I think I don't have to mention that the boomkin that critted all the time critted about 20% of the times.