T9vT10 feral idol for PvP

[Skultharion]

Which would be better?

Common sense tells me the T9 will stand out more in PvP, but maybe maths might prove me wrong.

Just needed some input, thanks

[Heywes]

how can you do the maths for it? pvp isn't as consistent.

I would guess t9 due to its easier to keep it up and its only a 44agil difference? Not too game breaking.

[leofric]

pvp isn't consistent.

I would guess t9 due to its easier to keep it up and its only a 20agil difference. Not game breaking.

Due to how rake works the stacking does not start until 3 seconds after the application. Assuming there are no breaks longer than ~15 seconds, the following results are in regards to the idols in question:

If you are not using 2pc T9, it takes ~116 seconds for Idol of the Crying Moon to be better than Idol of Mutilation.

If you are using 2pc T9, it takes ~106 seconds for Idol of the Crying Moon to be better than Idol of Mutilation.

So in short, for trash and for bosses where there are dps breaks (Lord Marrowgar's whirlwind, Lady Deathwhisper's adds, and Gunship battle) I would use Idol of Mutilation. But for fights where you need to do the most damage possible and will have no interruptions (like Deathbringer Saurfang) Idol of the Crying Moon would be better.

Therefor, I will not be upgrading to this idol until there is nothing left to upgrade, and no one else I know needs Primordial Saronite