As the title says, I was just curious as whats the best reason you've heard as to why a master looter ninja's an item?
I heard mine this wednesday in VoA 25. We just killed the new boss and the ML goes and inspects the loot. The ML is a mage and there is one other mage in the raid that actually did better DPS and actually targeted the orbs (something that most ranged still find hard to grasp but thats another story) So the 277 pvp mage legs drop. The ML immediately goes "right for pvp items I will go purely on who has the highest arena rating and offer it to them, I have a 1400 rating, the other mage has a 0 rating so im taking the legs" Now, as you can imagine there was a bit of an uproar for not even letting the other mage roll and alot of critisim to the ML for not saying the loot rules before looting.
Now before anyone says that its only fair that a pvper gets to roll on pvp gear, Im generally a pver but do a lot of BGs but dont do any arena. I have all the gear purchasable thru honor and have 1200 resilience. Now by the logic of the master looter I wouldnt of been entitled to any pvp gear if another warlock was in the raid and had any kind of rating.
For the record, when we killed the next couple bosses, the pvp items became free rolls aswell. So whats the reason you have all heard?