"Ideal" 10man *CLASS* Raid

[msdos]

Prot Pally
Prot Warrior

Resto druid
Disc Priest
Resto/Ele shaman

Afflic lock
Combat rogue
Unholy Dk
Arcane mage
MM Hunter

unholy DK buffs melee and spells simultaneously, while the shammy can drop windfury and cover the casters with ToW as ele.

[Elessa]

I lol at everyone putting MM as the hunters spec, when Survival is way better for 10 mans.

Care to elaborate? MM hunter is better in every way, if you have another class that gives replenishment.

[Jamara]

Would go with

Tanks:
Warrior Protection
Death Knight Blood

Healers:
Priest Discipline
Shaman Restoration
Paladin Holy

DPS:
Hunter Marksmanship
Druid Balance
Mage Arcane
Warlock Affliction
Rogue Combat

[Dessan]

Prot Warrior
Prot Pally

DK Unholy
Mage Frost
Rogue Ass
Hunter MM
Warlock Aff

Resto Sham
Disc Priest
Resto Druid

That or swap it to Warr + DK tank Boomkin and a Holy Pala

[Draeth]

Tank
Blood Death Knight
Protection Paladin

Healer
Holy Priest (Discipline Off-Spec: a double-healer dual spec isn't against the rules)
Restoration Druid
Restoration Shaman (Enhancement Off-Spec)

DPS
Arcane Mage (Fire Off-Spec for AoE fights)
Assassination Rogue
Demonology Warlock
Fury Warrior
Marksmanship Hunter

[Rozenwyn]

Prot Pally (cuz that's me...I'd have to bring myself right?)
Dk tank

Holy (or disc) priest...i just can't decide
Tree
Resto Shaman (oops, forgot to say this would be the off-spec. enhance, b/c i just love enhance shammies)

Fury warrior (cuz that's my bf, he's the best dps in guild by far, so i wouldn't leave him out for anything)
Arc mage
Lock, of any type really. As long as they have the skill, any spec can do more than decent.
MM hunter
Rogue....i dont know enough about them to pick a spec

[Elessa]

Prot Pally (cuz that's me...I'd have to bring myself right?)
Dk tank

Holy (or disc) priest...i just can't decide
Tree
Resto Shaman (oops, forgot to say this would be the off-spec. enhance, b/c i just love enhance shammies)

Fury warrior (cuz that's my bf, he's the best dps in guild by far, so i wouldn't leave him out for anything)
Arc mage
Lock, of any type really. As long as they have the skill, any spec can do more than decent.
MM hunter
Rogue....i dont know enough about them to pick a spec

Should really be destruction speced, since you will need replenishment.
The hunter can go Survival aswell, but Survival is a pretty weak spec compared to MM.

[Waterwings]

Tanks:
Prot Warrior
Bear Druid

Heals:
Holy Paladin
Holy Priest
Resto Shaman/OS Elemental

DPS:
Demo Warlock
Arcane Mage
MM Hunter
Unholy DK
Mut Rogue

*cough* usualy i make my raids with replenishment

Tanks:
Prot Warrior
Bear Druid

Heals:
Holy Paladin
Holy or disc Priest / Shadow offspecc
Resto Shaman

DPS:
Demo Warlock
Arcane Mage
MM or survival Hunter
Unholy DK
Mut Rogue

[M1kra]

Just since I wanna be in the group and I am Survival Hunter

Tank:
Blood Death Knight
Protection Warrior

Healer:
Holy / Shadow Priest
Restoration Shaman
Holy Paladin

DPS:
Demonology Warlock
Arcane Mage
Balance Druid
Survival Hunter
Combat Rogue

[Cpttrips]

Tanks
BEARw/boomkin OS
BEARw/resto OS
healers
TREEw/feral OS
TREEw boomkin OS
dps
BOOMKIN/w resto OS
BOOMKIN/w resto OS
BOOMKIN/w resto OS
FERAL/w resto OS
FERAL/w resto OS

what can i say us druids are da bomb ;D

[borbes]

Tanks:
Protection Warrior
Blood DK

Heals:
Holy Paladin
Resto Druid
Resto Shaman

DPS:
Shadow Priest
MM Hunter
Arcane Mage
Rogue
Warlock

There's really not that many decisions to make. 4/5 DPS slots have to be the pure classes, and only 1 healing class can be anything but healing. So it really it becomes a question of which hybrid DPS do you want? Shadow Priests own in 10-mans. They give you replenishment, raid healing, amazing AOE (vilespiritslol), and unmatched survivability. If you want a Shadow Priest, then the other 3 healing classes have to heal, meaning you have to bring a Prot Warrior and DK tank.

[Deleted]

Dk Tank
Druid Tank

Pala Healer
Priest Healer - DPS offspec
Shaman Healer

Rogue combat
Warrior fury
Hunter mm
Warlock demo
Mage arcane

Dont people know that warrior tanks are useless and fury warriors are insane?

Well, not many fury warriors like to keep sunder up

[Rozenwyn]

Should really be destruction speced, since you will need replenishment.
The hunter can go Survival aswell, but Survival is a pretty weak spec compared to MM.

I've done plenty of raids without replenishment, its convenient for sure, but you won't omgdie without it. So for me, it would be whatever spec the lock/hunter are comfortable playing and do their best as. I'm all about playing what you want to play, not what the cookie cutters say you should play.

[borbes]

I've done plenty of raids without replenishment, its convenient for sure, but you won't omgdie without it. So for me, it would be whatever spec the lock/hunter are comfortable playing and do their best as. I'm all about playing what you want to play, not what the cookie cutters say you should play.

You fail at reading the subject/OP. No Replenishment is not 'ideal' which was what was asked for.

[Rozenwyn]

You fail at reading the subject/OP. No Replenishment is not 'ideal' which was what was asked for.

You fail at reading what I said. It would be MY ideal raid. MY ideal raid is people playing what they are most comfortable/happy with. So that everyone has fun. WoW is not a 2nd job. It is a game. Sure, when you're raiding, you want it to be efficient so you can progress. But, to me, it's about fun too. And since it would be MY raid, I wouldn't want someone playing a spec they don't want to play.

[Qruz]

Prot warrior
Tanking DK

Holy paladin
Resto druid
Disc / shadow priest

Hunter
Warlock
Mage
Rogue
Elemental Shaman

[borbes]

You fail at reading what I said. It would be MY ideal raid. MY ideal raid is people playing what they are most comfortable/happy with. So that everyone has fun. WoW is not a 2nd job. It is a game. Sure, when you're raiding, you want it to be efficient so you can progress. But, to me, it's about fun too. And since it would be MY raid, I wouldn't want someone playing a spec they don't want to play.

I didn't fail at all. You're off-topic. OP didn't ask for what you find fun... he asked for maximum potential. He doesn't give a flying hoohoo what you are most comfortable with. Create a new topic if you really want to post what makes you happy. Otherwise, stay on topic.

[Elessa]

You fail at reading what I said. It would be MY ideal raid. MY ideal raid is people playing what they are most comfortable/happy with. So that everyone has fun. WoW is not a 2nd job. It is a game. Sure, when you're raiding, you want it to be efficient so you can progress. But, to me, it's about fun too. And since it would be MY raid, I wouldn't want someone playing a spec they don't want to play.

I agree with you. But to be realistic, you couldn't do any ICC heroic fight without replenishment, and not struggle because of it.
On Saurfang 10man heroic, I regened a bit over 20k mana (holy paladin) from replenishment, that's about 3 full pleas. 3 full pleas = a 45 second window where the tank + the mark you are healing have a 100% higher chance to die.

If you were to make YOUR ideal raid, with everyone liking the spec they play, you should really find someone who enjoys playing a spec with replenishment.

[Iacom]

Tanks:
Prot Warrior
Bear Druid

Heals:
Holy Paladin
Discipline Priest
Resto Shaman/OS Elemental

DPS:
Demo Warlock
Arcane Mage
Survival Hunter
Unholy DK
Combat Rogue

[Darios]

I'd say one of every class, duelspecced for functionality