How good is NMIC?

[Fligahgigook]

How good is NMIC when you can roll corr the whole fight? Is it > than DFO+Spyglass? BiS in that situation? Does the rolling effect work when simming it?

[Goatonlb]

on fights where you can pull off 100% corruption uptime
dfo/NMIC

on all others
dfo/phlyactery

[awebz]

you technically only have to be able to roll cor for 3 minute intervals

[Fligahgigook]

Thanks

[ComputerNerd]

A decent sim should take the rolling into effect.
Providing you can keep it rolling, then it is superior to the other 10 man trinkets.
The heroic versions though are comparable enough if not superior so will be of a lot more benefit when you cannot keep the rolling crit, which is more likely on the heroic mode fights.

[Warlocomotif]

on fights where you can pull off 100% corruption uptime
dfo/NMIC

on all others
dfo/phlyactery

This was entirely true before the buff to phylactry, now however heroic phylactry does beat NMIC even in fights where you keep it rolling. Personally I don't think I'd use NMIC over the normal version of NMIC either- sure it's 10 or so more dps, but chances of you synching all the other things up properly are reduced noticably.

[Goatonlb]

Agreed, I didn't mean anything heroic. If you have access to heroic gear, you probabaly know the answer already.