That one Item...

[Einari]

Dislodged Foreign Object

50 times now and no luck

i suppose you are aware of the fact that rotface hasnt been out for 50 weeks yet. try again next year

[Jerigothiel]

for me its "War Mace of Unrequited Love" drops in HC nexus i went there 27 times no drop then i got something better from naxx.
its like a knife in the hearth when it dops and i press DE on it.

[DakeshiSB]

Dislodged Foreign Object

50 times now and no luck

I didn't know icecrown citadel had been out for 50 weeks

[Soranis]

Your mom

[Volroth]

http://www.wowhead.com/item=40432

I Sarth every week and i saw it drop once, and a 1k dps mage rolls a 99.

[babyback]

Your mom

I see what you did there...

Not amused though

[Shalaman]

Scepter of Terenas II

[Waalt]

Until yesterday it was Satrina's Impeding Scarab, lost the roll however I bought it for 11.5k gold tho ;D ;D

[Necroparadox]

VoA t10 tank hands. i dont care if its 251 or 264 give me my damned hands!!!

[Deleted]

Farming D1-Set was a pain (also known as T0). I ran Stratholme Bastion 123 times for the shoes, lost them twice to stupid warriors during that time. Got the flask recipe several times, the epic drops from the boss, but the shoes only on my 123rd run.

Then I had to run UBRS 75 times for my breastplate.

Both of those were replaced during two weeks as (thanks to my full t0 and fire resist gear) I was able to join the best guild on my server, running MC and BWL at the time.

Nostalgia for classic? Not for me.

[Frozen]

Any mount that is a rare drop.

[Fenz]

Shadowmoon Destroyer's Cape

[Sápphh]

Dps boots from HoR. 23 kills and they didn't drop. Then I got the boots from Gunship 10 man. And then the boots dropped in my next two runs.. FML.

[Irishform]

Dreadboots of the Legion from Reliquary of Souls in BT... never quite got them after many months farming at 70.

[thunderchunk]

Spark of Hope.

Fuck you, Kologarn.

[babyback]

Dps boots from HoR. 23 kills and they didn't drop. Then I got the boots from Gunship 10 man. And then the boots dropped in my next two runs.. FML.

23 kills in HoR, thats like...nothing

[Eldinfre]

Back before my guild cleared Putricide, Bonebreaker Scepter off Marrowgar was really the only weapon upgrade I could get outside of ToGC25. First time we cleared Putricide, The Facelifter dropped, which went to me, being the only tank that can use swords (our off-tank is a bear). The next week, Bonebreaker dropped, and has every week since.

The only other thing that has eluded my grasp is Unidetifiable Organ , which went to our Bear the week I ended up with Facelifter, but we haven't seen it since and happens to be the last thing I need in ICC 10 normal. Go figure.

[DerSenf]

http://www.wowhead.com/item=11086
...86 kills til i finally got it. Screw you, 9% chance!
I never want to make that stupid stair event in ZF again... ever!

[Deleted]

The blue Dungeon set in BC.

Farmed heroic Mechanar for the head to my hunter, NEVER saw it dropped. Even got exalted with Sha'tar but still no head.

[Elanale]

Pretty much anything a Warlock might conceivably want out of ICC.