Ret Weapon Question

[toaster234]

What do you think i should use cryptmaker or the Oathbinder the polearm that drops off of lich 25m
Oathbinder has agility on it
Cryptmaker is more of a warrior weapon with the armorpen

thanks hop to here some responses!

[Wonderboy]

RAWR

[DaGhostDS]

both arent the best, but i would say Oathbinder if you dont need the hit and cryptmaker if you do

[Scifix]

Oathbinder is apparently way better for rets than cryptmaker

[DaGhostDS]

Oathbinder is apparently way better for rets than cryptmaker

thats because of the crit you get from it, with BoK it goes up to 5.6%

[toaster234]

ok thanks if anyone else has any opnions it always helps!

---------- Post added 06-18-2010 at 09:47 PM ----------

btw http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...rusher&cn=Xahe
and i know my wep isnt socketed or enchanted

[Telm]

LIke everyone else has stated above take Oathbinder if you dont need Hit from Cryptmaker.

[ammor]

When I checked your armory I saw you with Cryptmaker equiped, and at 449 hit
Being over Hit cap can be a DPS loss, plus its just a wastage of hit for you, Oathbringer or w/e the Polearm is from LK 25 is way better for you as it utilizes more stats that you can use then just a wastage of hit and armpen...Go with the Polearm for sure, or Bryntroll, or Glorenzelg may be an option for you as well

[Croack]

U should get Bryntroll heroic, Bloodfall heroic or the Or the oathbinger hc and replace ring and neck with Skeleton lord's circle and sindragosa cruel claw and u'r crit and hit will be just fine heres my armory if it helps :http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...ight&cn=Croack
And yeah use rawr :http://rawr.codeplex.com/releases/45879/download/123609

[Adoris]

If you are looking into ICC25man weapons, i'd suggest either Bryntroll or the polearm from Blood queen Lana'thel. Truth be told Cryptmaker will benefit a warrior or even a DK much more than a ret paladin.

[toaster234]

ok thanks anything else i need to know feel free to let me know!

[Praxius1]

You have too much hit... and the oathbinder has overall better stats if you don't use the hit... so ye, Oathbinder.

[Brael]

Oathbinder easily, not only due to the weapon dps but you don't and probably never will, need the hit from Cryptmaker.

[Nighty]

why are you wearing prot gloves?

[Nillo]

What do you think i should use cryptmaker or the Oathbinder the polearm that drops off of lich 25m
Oathbinder has agility on it
Cryptmaker is more of a warrior weapon with the armorpen

thanks hop to here some responses!
http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...rusher&cn=Xahe

1) Agi items are usually better than Str items (if the other stats are comparable) => Oathbinder is better
2) If you're talking about non heroic weapons Oathbinder is 7 lvl higher !_! => Oathbinder is far better
3) Get the leather badge belt yours is crap at 400 hit.