Is shadows edge better than.

[Scottishpaladin]

If shadows edge better than bryntroll now? they nerfed bryntroll I though? just a wquick question before I got getting Shadows edge for my pala too :P?

[Adoris]

Do you mean the normal mode version of Bryntroll or the heroic one?
In my opinion Shadow's edge is slightly better than the normal version. Although i'd recommend not bothering with Shadow's edge, unless you actually have a shot at the Shadowmourne questchain.

But that's just my PoV, feel free to do whatever you see fit :>

[Scottishpaladin]

Yes normal version bryntroll, And since im no longer in a proggessive guild I mostly likely dont have a shot at shadowmourne. Bryntroll is possible but pugs dont seem to be able to kill the spikes during bonstorm . But overall is it better than normal one?

[Gavenrod]

Assuming you're following Frmorrison's (Elitistjerks.com) BiS list, he states the following best weapons and an order of what edges out what, which I'm going to list here until I can post links. -.-

Shadowmourne - > Oathbinder, Charge of the Ranger-General [Heroic] - > Glorenzelg, High-Blade of the Silver Hand [Heroic] - > Bloodfall [Heroic] - > Bryntroll, the Bone Arbiter [Heroic] - > Warmace of Menethil [Heroic] - > Cryptmaker [Heroic] - > Oathbinder, Charge of the Ranger-General - > Glorenzelg, High-Blade of the Silver Hand - > Shadow's Edge - > Wrathful Gladiator's Claymore - > Oxheart - > Ramaladni's Blade of Culling - > Bloodfall - > Hersir's Greatspear - > Bryntroll, the Bone Arbiter

Hope this helps. :P

[Suliso]

Shadow's Edge is about 126 dps +-, depends on gear, better than Bryntroll
Heroic Bryntroll is better than Shadow's Edge but I don't have any numbers for those -.-

[Scottishpaladin]

think ill get myself a cheeky shadows edge to try it out 126dps can make all the differenece after all. Thanks for the replys