First WoL parse:
Obliterate 458380 23.7 % 13 7216.5 93814 20
18228.3 364566 - - - -
Obliterate 326779 16.9 % 13 5126.6 66646 20
13006.6 260133 - - - -
So, you conveniently look at ONLY the strike with the mainhand? As far as I know 18k+13k=31k ON AVARAGE.
Also, you DO have a point with the 25%buff, but at the moment the case is that we do have the buff, and the poster of the WoLparse uses it as his proof.
So actually 31/125 x 100 =
24.8k AVERAGE CRIT OUTSIDE ICC.
Second WoL Parse:
Obliterate 712862 22.7 % 16 7983.0 127728 29
19861.7 575989
Obliterate 488020 15.5 % 19 5705.6 108407 27
14059.7 379613
((19,8617+14,0594)/125) x 100 = 27,13668 ~
27k AVERAGE CRIT OUTSIDE ICC.
Oh my, beaten by math