Ok so considering hes gonna be the new leader of the horde no matter how much we bitch and whine about it, lets just get whatever kinks that exist atm out of the way.
Cons: Blockheaded, looks like a mammoth ear fucked a tree, has a square foot, sends a fleet of blimp defending ships to go pew pew allys before getting overrun by twilight dragons, racist (to some extent), makes tension within the core horde races (troll/orc/tauren), gives Lady S a reason to kill him, opens a can of wtfbbqwarohshit on the alliance, is a mouthbreather, and does indeed have some patchy lore that will be retcon'd the FUCK up
Pros: Since we have last seen him in Northrend, he seems to have gained a sense of honor from Cleavefang, as seen in the QQ over Lady S rezzing more dead, the incident with Stonetalon Peak (yelling at the general or w/e who killed innocents up there), the incident with Cairne (he helped drive the Grimtotem out after the whole "omfgCairnesdead" scene), Facecleaves a dragon, Finally put Maggy's head to use (though, again, he looks like a mammoth ear fucked a tree), made Org look leet, and for some good measure put more of a pvp element back in WoW rather than the "oh hai thare gaiz lets team up and beat up the baddys" which was Northrend (dont get me wrong there was pvp elements too but...ffs not enough)
So yes, Garrosh has a shitload of cons, and yet has some pros aswell. Is he going to run us into the ground? Doubt it considering Blizz controls the lore and I doubt they are gonna cut off one of the two major factions in the game. Will Garrosh be killed and replaced? Only time can tell, I mean shit consider the fact that he has had two major personality shifts since his introduction in BC so for all we know after some events happen in Cata and we start to get knee deep into it, Garrosh may or may not make choices that actually benifit both his own charater and the horde ontop of it. Now this is all hypothesis, so for all we know anything can happen at the point, as for what WILL happen we will just have to wait for Cata to judge for ourselves. Now then no more "Garrosh QQ" threads plox.