Originally Posted by
aristocle
You know WoW is something truly special. It endeavoured to make the MMORPG more accessible to a larger playerbase, and as such people like me who never played MMO's was drawn to one.
That said. There comes a time in every games life to finally put down its hold on the market, and as such newer and better games will and have arrived. Interestingly enough the game is also showing its age in more ways then one. The paper mache tree leaves, the flat low quality ground textures, spray painted gear that looks like spandex on your toons, and even its game engine built from its own RTS series are antiques. Plenty of people love playing older games, and this is one that definitely won't be leaving the market any year soon. Some may even find those older games to be far more enjoyable! Goldeneye [N64} anyone?
It is truly honorable that Blizzard wants to revitalize its MMO world champ as something new and up to date. Surely many will love the leveling to 85 process, the revamped old world zones, and new races as they will continue to love the game out of loyalty if anything. Yet nothing could save this game besides a sweeping overhaul of the engine and complete remake of the old race animations and spells. The kind of change that would take far more time and work then even Blizzard would be ever willing to devote to its cherished title.
Perhaps their new MMO will once again blow us away in more ways then one. Yet, if anything I believe that Runic and ArenaNet will perhaps revitalize the market in exciting new ways if Blizzard fails to. With Tochlight 2 perhaps as a guinea pig for their future Torchlight MMO things look very good for Runic. Arenanet has amassed serious buzz with Guild Wars 2, and Red 5's new scifi free shooter MMO FireFall looks to be interesting as well.
I think its time to put aside denial. This game, WoW, was and will continue to be here as a reminder of what went right with the MMO. However, and this is hard to say, its time for it to finally move aside.
Blizzard had its time to shine with WoW, Cataclysm won't help it.