- Whether someone replying can do what you did is irrelevant
- How much effort and time you guys personally put into the kill is irrelevant
- 30% Buff makes up way more than not having 25man gears: FACT
- Therefore, early guilds that have killed it with 0-15%~buff had less stats than you in every way despite them having 25man gears: FACT
- Therefore, you beat the exact encounter with the exact same mechanics, with more relative stats than 100-300 other guilds that have killed it: FACT
So to sum it up: These forums are for actual first kills, or some actually amazing first achievements (Rogue Solo Naxx, DK solo OS, etc). It is not for some random guilds (with random mage that doesn't even know how to gear themselves) asking for recognitions for their subpar kill, that they forcefully call it a "4th" by setting an arbitrary requirement.
Yes, I'm sure it is hard for you guys, and I'm sure it will impress few people, but this is not the place for it. So please stop making these "US first Dragon Kill playing with One Hand without wearing pants!"