I really loved the fact I had a PVP title from vanilla. People would see it and go "Dayum, you've been here a while."
Couldn't they just make new titles and let those of us who have been around for many years keep them? I always saw it as like having the ZG bear mount type of Feat of Strength reward for being a long time player.
I was kind of sad to see they are letting new people acquire them.