Originally Posted by
Caine
You're missing the entire point here. No one is saying all MCs should be super-dramatic, I know that. However, what people are saying here is that Inaho is cardboard, a box, rock, has no emotions, is emotionless, is expressionless. And all that is completely false. He shows a lot of emotion - however, he does so not by theatrical overexpression commonly seen in MCs all around the globe, but in a much more subtle way. And that subtlety apparently goes way over the heads. Hence the presumption: unless the MC employs theatrics he is treated as emotionless. Anything less subtle than gumface expressions a'la Nisekoi is not enough.