Wrap of the Great Turtle

[Twisted Spirit]

I am in the process of gearing my dps kitty into a tank.

Is wrap of the great turtle a good tanking cloak considering the dodge and mastery? Or does it lag behind because of its strength instead of agility?

Many thanks

[tangedyn]

AEP values from my current gear and bear spreadsheet in my sig

Wrap of the Great Turtle over Cloak of Thredd gives:
+45 Armor (x 0.6353 = 28.58 AEP)
+190 Strength (x 0.3141 = 59.68 AEP)
-168 Agility (-168 AEP)
+31 Stamina (x 0.1923 / x 1.0940 = 5.96 AEP / 33.91 AEP)
+15 Mastery (x 0.4626 = 6.94 AEP)
-68 Crit (x 0.3332 = -22.66 AEP)
+83 Dodge (x 0.6468 = 53.68 AEP)

Which is either a loss of -7.87 AEP (using TTL model) or -35.82 AEP (using damage reduction model)

Either way, the Cloak of Thredd is better

[Twisted Spirit]

I have yet to enter Deadmines on my druid. I spent so much time gearing my DK that my Druid got forgotten!

Haste is a bad stat for bears right?

Also on the cloak of thredd should i be reforging the crit to dodge?

[Fojos]

I have yet to enter Deadmines on my druid. I spent so much time gearing my DK that my Druid got forgotten!

Haste is a bad stat for bears right?

Also on the cloak of thredd should i be reforging the crit to dodge?

Yes to both questions.