Rate the Hunter above you!

[adamthehunter]

http: //us.battle.net/wow/en/character/stonemaul/koochii/advanced

Not too bad for your gear level. Belt Buckle + another gem would be your only issue. Socketing for stat bonus < 20 agi is normally frowned upon except it looks like you needed that 10 hit so that's fine. Once you get hit elsewhere, reforge your trinkets to crit. Yes, even Fluid Death.

Click the sig for the armory. The BM spec is purely to tame Skoll, which I'm camping as I type this. Usually have my PvP spec in there

[Lilyana]

Legs could be tweaked a bit. +30 agi bonus is quite high. Going with:

40 agi
20 agi + 20 crit
20 agi + 20 hit

Nets 110 agi with socket bonus. Currently you roll with 120 agi, which is 10 more agility for the loss of 20 crit and 20 hit. While it probably isn't worth fiddling with right now it could be as you upgrade or get slightly more hit than you need and can then reforge excess to crit. And I question beauty's collar. I'm not sure thats ideal for marks spec....! (your hunter looks great and it is hard to find fault!).

[adamthehunter]

Legs could be tweaked a bit. +30 agi bonus is quite high. Going with:

40 agi
20 agi + 20 crit
20 agi + 20 hit

Nets 110 agi with socket bonus. Currently you roll with 120 agi, which is 10 more agility for the loss of 20 crit and 20 hit. While it probably isn't worth fiddling with right now it could be as you upgrade or get slightly more hit than you need and can then reforge excess to crit. And I question beauty's collar. I'm not sure thats ideal for marks spec....! (your hunter looks great and it is hard to find fault!).

Thanks for the kind words.

I've been debating the gemming all day, but ultimately I'd be losing my best stat to my 2nd best stat (2nd by a long shot) and my worst stat (I'm already hit capped, so it's a wasted stat).

[Distance335]

For Lilyana. Looks really good, just a few things I would change:

- Go straight agi in your legs, it's better than using hybrid gems for that particular bonus.
- Mix up your reforging a bit; you're over hit cap by a large-ish amount. Or it might be easier to just lose the purple gem in your gloves (putting you only 4 over cap).
- I assume Survival is your PvE spec. You might want to consider moving 2 points out of One With Nature and putting them in Sic 'Em!, you should see improvement.

Other than those minor things you look solid!

Sadly I can't post links until I get my post count up, but it's in my sig. Critiques welcome!

[Konik]

You might want to consider moving 2 points out of One With Nature and putting them in Sic 'Em!, you should see improvement.

wrong

use femaledwarf.com

[awarietta]

Well, I wouldn't say flat out wrong. Although femaledwarf gives the best dps, it is on a standstill patchwerk fight and is only a simulator. If you are never in hawk or constantly moving and kiting, One With Nature could be a less desirable talent. It would depend on what the raid needs, as well as your playstayle.

[Konik]

there are not so many fights where you are constantly moving and if so you should use aspect switching for major shots

[adamthehunter]

One with Nature should be 3/3 in every spec you have. It's 200ap per point, and that's a lot for just one talent point. Aspect Dancing is something hunters will now have to perfect to get every ounce of DPS out.

[Radio]

For Lilyana. Looks really good, just a few things I would change:

- Go straight agi in your legs, it's better than using hybrid gems for that particular bonus.
- Mix up your reforging a bit; you're over hit cap by a large-ish amount. Or it might be easier to just lose the purple gem in your gloves (putting you only 4 over cap).
- I assume Survival is your PvE spec. You might want to consider moving 2 points out of One With Nature and putting them in Sic 'Em!, you should see improvement.

Other than those minor things you look solid!

Sadly I can't post links until I get my post count up, but it's in my sig. Critiques welcome!

You seem to be doing a good job and heading in the right direction for heroic progression, 10/10 based on your progression.

http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...skpup/advanced
^^ Is mine

[cymoro]

Your hit is over the cap. This can be fixed to make better use of your 2ndary stats
http://www.reforgecalc.de/
Will give you all combinations equaling out to exactly 8% hit. FD shows a reforging change could improve your ideal DPS by almost 100.

Otherwise without seeing some raid logs, tough to find anything bad to say :-)

Armory:
http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...recks/advanced
Only fight I've done so far with my current gear setup:
http://www.worldoflogs.com/reports/a...s=9914&e=10143

[hakai]

Your hit is over the cap. This can be fixed to make better use of your 2ndary stats
http://www.reforgecalc.de/
Will give you all combinations equaling out to exactly 8% hit. FD shows a reforging change could improve your ideal DPS by almost 100.

Otherwise without seeing some raid logs, tough to find anything bad to say :-)

Armory (ignore the half-hearted PVP gear/spec. I'll have to switch it out tonight):
http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...recks/advanced
Only fight I've done so far with my current gear setup:
http://www.worldoflogs.com/reports/a...s=9914&e=10143

I don't know what to really rate you on in PvP gear, I see you have access to heroic gear, and have a successful raiding history though. Re-post in PvE gear if you can. Oh, putting 2 in Shark Attack instead of 1 in it, and Wild hunter is more DPS. Around 70+. I have MM and SV pets though. MM is 2/2 in Wild Hunt, SV is 2/2 Shark Attack.

Here is my armory for anyone to rate...
http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...mahll/advanced

We are still working on P3 Nefarian >.>

[Darkelementz]

I don't know what to really rate you on in PvP gear, I see you have access to heroic gear, and have a successful raiding history though. Re-post in PvE gear if you can.

Here is my armory for anyone to rate...
http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...mahll/advanced

We are still working on P3 Nefarian >.>

I'd love to rate you but you have the EXACT same gear as I do (except the belt). I'm a little torn about using sic 'em or careful aim as survival since it only affects cobra shot 20% of the time, whereas it increases your pet's damage (if you spec it to do more damage with more focus). Aside from that, you are my troll twin brother haha

[hakai]

I'd love to rate you but you have the EXACT same gear as I do (except the belt). I'm a little torn about using sic 'em or careful aim as survival since it only affects cobra shot 20% of the time, whereas it increases your pet's damage (if you spec it to do more damage with more focus). Aside from that, you are my troll twin brother haha

xD Um, I messed around with Sic 'em but Careful Aim is still more DPS.

[cymoro]

As MM, FD shows going 2/2 Shark attack as a 340+ DPS loss
2/2 Wild hunt is a 13 DPS loss
compared to 1/2 each

My gear has been updated:
Armory:
http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...recks/advanced
Only fight I've done so far with my current gear setup:
http://www.worldoflogs.com/reports/a...s=9914&e=10143

Current MM spec is to test MM on cho'gall rather than SV so I switch around some point a bit that I normally would have elsewhere dealing with multishot

I don't know what to really rate you on in PvP gear, I see you have access to heroic gear, and have a successful raiding history though. Re-post in PvE gear if you can. Oh, putting 2 in Shark Attack instead of 1 in it, and Wild hunter is more DPS. Around 70+. I have MM and SV pets though. MM is 2/2 in Wild Hunt, SV is 2/2 Shark Attack.

Here is my armory for anyone to rate...
http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...mahll/advanced

We are still working on P3 Nefarian >.>

[hakai]

As MM, FD shows going 2/2 Shark attack as a 340+ DPS loss
2/2 Wild hunt is a 13 DPS loss
compared to 1/2 each

My gear has been updated:
Armory:
http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...recks/advanced
Only fight I've done so far with my current gear setup:
http://www.worldoflogs.com/reports/a...s=9914&e=10143

Current MM spec is to test MM on cho'gall rather than SV so I switch around some point a bit that I normally would have elsewhere dealing with multishot

I meant 2/2 Shark Attack as SV, since we go 3 into BM now for AP. MM is still 2/2 Wild Hunt.

[Distance335]

wrong

use femaledwarf.com

Ah I see, I had her pet using common pet spec on the spread sheet. You're right, it's about 12 dps higher with 2/2 shark attack.

EDIT: The reason that I don't take it is that with my gear I only pick up 3.41 dps on the spreadsheet, not enough to offset even the smallest amount of movement.

EDIT 2: I also don't show 2/2 Wild Hunt as preferable for Marks, looking at a loss of 75.98 dps versus 1 in each. Could you explain your reasoning?

[Dvorjak]

No link above me:

http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...orjak/advanced

[Redpanda]

Pretty nice set up. 10/10 im very jelly of your staff

http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte.../redrun/simple

im sure something is off but i dont know what.

[Kennpai]

Your reforging is all over the place, try using reforgecalc.de the MM Crit>Haste>Mastery template. 50 agility to bracer is better then crit, 2 agilitys in your pants is a dps increase albeit 30 or so, Still worth it imo. Please tell me your spec is for Cho'gall, 2/3 or 3/3 pathing is all you take in SV, Then you go 2/3 bestial discipline, 2/3 or 3/3 Frenzy, No glyph of steady shot either? Your main ability and you aren't buffing it.

Overall very lack luster, 7/10

Myself: http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...elbak/advanced

I haven't attempted to raid on my hunter in the past 2 weeks, though if I did Themios is still a myth.

[Deleted]

Seeing as you're playing AiS MM are you sure Crit is worth more than haste for you?
I found it to be a massive loss to reforge for crit instead of haste - which would mean dropping a point in frenzy for pathing.
You might want to consider getting assassin's step as well but your boots are only 359 so only do it if you're loaded.

Everything else seems fine - 9/10

http://eu.battle.net/wow/en/characte...%A9la/advanced