What do YOU think Communism is?

[atsawin26]

And they keep falling back to that fallacy with feeble attempts to justify it.

[Tharaldriel]

And they keep falling back to that fallacy with feeble attempts to justify it.

Are you even reading our arguments to the contrary...?

[murfle]

why ya so nice to fucks and low lifes?

[Fûrious_]

And they keep falling back to that fallacy with feeble attempts to justify it.

How can one person be so stubborn...

[smrund]

And they keep falling back to that fallacy with feeble attempts to justify it.

Possibly, but you're the one calling a man a unicorn because he's got a cone taped to his head.

[atsawin26]

Are you even reading our arguments to the contrary...?

I'm reading apologists attempting to defend their logical inconsistency.

[Tharaldriel]

Possibly, but you're the one calling a man a unicorn because he's got a cone taped to his head.

This is my new sig.

[smrund]

I'm reading apologists attempting to defend their logical inconsistency.

Nobody here is an apologist since Communism has never actually done anything.

[Tharaldriel]

I'm reading apologists attempting to defend their logical inconsistency.

Argue, then, consistently, against everything we've said to counter your ridiculous argument.

[atsawin26]

Did you get your political education working in Hot Topic?

[Fûrious_]

This is my new sig.

!!!!!!!!! xD

[smrund]

This is my new sig.

thanks! that's twice this week that someone has sig-quoted me.

[electrikfuzz]

Actually, it's more like this.

Let's assume that all zebras are friendly.

Now, we have a white horse who is a bit of a bitch. This white horse paints itself with black stripes. It then commits murder and adultery.

What you're saying is that, according to the above argument, zebras now commit murder and adultery regularly.

He pointed out a logical fallacy in your argument. Attempting to make an analogy out of an invalid argument doesn't address anything he has said.

[A Forum Troll]

Possibly, but you're the one calling a man a unicorn because he's got a cone taped to his head.

That's low. For too long have my unicorn brethren suffered to the ignorance of your kin.
For far too long have we been called "Crazy lunitics with cones strapped to their forheads".
For far too long! But no more.

I don't have to sit and listen to this.

[Tharaldriel]

He pointed out a logical fallacy in your argument. Attempting to make an analogy out of an invalid argument doesn't address anything he has said.

And I pointed out that his logical fallacy does not match out argument, and attached a more accurate analogy to it.

[Tesk]

Essentially its the ideal concept... but its broken and doesnt work in society

[Doktor Faustus]

I don't know what Communism is 'cos I was brought up and indocrinated in the 1980's :P

Seriously, the Soviet Union was no more communist than the 'West' is democratic... do capitalism and democracy sit hand in hand?

[atsawin26]

And I pointed out that his logical fallacy does not match out argument, and attached a more accurate analogy to it.

It matches perfectly, Communists, like religious apologists, never fail to fall back on the DEY NOT REEL COMMUNISTS skit, which is exactly what the No True Scotsman Fallacy is.

But hey, if you want to be illogical, go ahead, it goes hand in hand with your ideology.

[DaHomieG]

Russia, China and Cuba is all that comes to mind.

[Fûrious_]

It matches perfectly, Communists, like religious apologists, never fail to fall back on the DEY NOT REEL COMMUNISTS skit, which is exactly what the No True Scotsman Fallacy is.

But hey, if you want to be illogical, go ahead, it goes hand in hand with your ideology.

He never said "they are no real communists" he said "they simply are no communists" the real makes the big difference here...