I honestly don't know how Phili could have given up JVR for Schenn 1 on 1. Schenn had 1 good season and got worse and worse every year, last year he looked like he couldn't control the puck or make a lengthy pass to save his life. His only strength seemed to be solid hitting last year. I don't think he'd make Oilers any better defensively; They need real top tier defenders right now to become a serious threat.