This has little to do with the goalies. Gustavsson can go to a dozen other teams and be capable of making second or third round with a bit more confidence, less regard for the media, and dedicated players willing to block shots. Worst thing was taking Gustavsson out of net (while he was incredibly hot) once Reimer came back, that was just all sorts of fail on everyone involved in that decision followed by that rotating goalie bullshit.
Aside from that, we have one offensive line bringing their all game in and out (except against Boston) along with one player on the second game, and Mike Brown. Changing a goalie every year hasn't helped us any more than when we boo'd Raycroft out of the city. They just don't, for whatever reason, play well defensively.