Is this fight based on RNG as much as it seems? We have been getting to p2 with our eyes closed forever now with many different group makeups and wipe anywhere between 0.5% and 10% every time. We hit p2 and our tanks usually get destroyed instantly.... maybe its unlucky with dodging but double attack stomps the first tank and then the next tank to get aggro is the Ret pally who isnt really a tank, he bubbles which makes our 2nd real tank get it , by that time the next double attack is queued and that tank pops every CD and usually dies or survives the Dbl attack and dies to next melee swing....
By the time our rogue gets aggro to do some evasion tanking most of the other dps are already dead, he says he is vanishing for part of his rotation so thats why he gets aggro last.
Any way to last longer with this makeup going into p2:
Blood Tank
Feral Tank
Ret Pally (Tanking breaks)
Resto shaman x2
Holy Pally
Hunter x2
Rogue
Fury warrior