Agreed he's not in that sorry of a state as WW or Taric, though he is incredibly stat-checky. If at any point, he's powerful, he'll just outright tank the entire enemy team and get a pentakill out of it. He's already borderline powerful, though the recent nerf really screwed him over.
Mostly though, it's just not delivering on the promise of a tactician. It does, however, deliver on the "Oh, let's just morph and eat them" premise. I hope they retain that bit.