but a brief list where its obtainable.
first pick: pvp reputation set (blue) from TBC with different factions at honored,
weapon is toc10 heroic anub. shield from supremus i think.
boots was just random from mogit.
belt quest reward from Nrend.
second is LFR warrior lookalike from different bosses.
weapon is from maloriak in BWD
shield from Felmyst SWP
I have just recently aquired my Holy Warrior Set and I'm in a bit of a pickle.
I can't figure out what Weapon, Shield, Tabard and Cloak will fit best.
So, I thought to myself - why not just ask? I guess everybody has their own preferences and we could compile some nice outfits:
(Click pictures for enlarged version)
Outfit: Wrathful Gladiator Sword + Schield / August Celestials Tabard / Non-Transmogged Melee DPS Legendary Cloak
Wait, are the epic cloaks not xmoggable from the 5.3 quest? I figured when they turned orange they'd be not up for xmog but as epics...
If you are able to xmog a cloak, I recommend the good old Permafrost Cape: http://www.wowhead.com/item=69878
You can use Bastion of Light from Hyjal or Bulwark of Algalon from Algalon of course. Those two are kind of out of the norm. Others might be Cataclysmic Galdiator's Redoubt if you're into small shields, Northern Barrier if you don't mind the slight color difference, or Good ole' Bulwark of Azzinoth.
Not sure if you decided on a weapon yet Riemu but Hailstorm looks pretty neat with that armour in my opinion.
As for a shield, eh I know a few protection Paladins use Stormshield of Renewal on my realm, might look a bit small on a Tauren though, current tabard seems rather neat though with that set.
Caress of Insanity (1h Mace) and Barricade of Eternity match the pally CM set perfectly. Pair with Tabard of the Lightbringer and you're golden.