Why would they even need a choice, no warrior tank is going to pick a 2h agi wep so they could just make it an automatic process based on your class.Also for those saying "no legendaries for bears because you wouldn't see it", the fire cat staff kind of ruins idea, it would be easy for them to make the legendary change the bear model of that to a bear with large plate armor, or made of rock, or whatever they want.Would not feel legendary at all then + making epic awesome questline ending with 3 different items would be the impossible thing, since we have multiple 'phases' for new legendaries
People should start understand that legendary items have a big lore behind them, and that you can't just say let's make a quest and you pick any item you want from the list. If someone has been known to wield a legendary staff, and people get a quest for it to recraft it, it's a big difference changing the powers of the staff depending on the wielder , or just say well for you it will actually be a caster axe, and for the other it was actually a legendary mace. It has nothing to do with not being able to make a quest like that, but with any logic trying to maintain in the game. We are talking legendary's not simple questitems you can pick from a list.
Also for people saying rogues should be somewhere down the list , the legendary wielders from last till rogues :
Mage, Priest, Druid, Warlock, Shaman
Paladin, Death Knight, Warrior
Druid, Priest, Paladin, Shaman
Meaning all others had their legendary's since.
If you look like class specs instead, than the common named Enha SHaman and Feral hunter could have used Sulfuras, but an assassination rogue could not have any legendary as a main weapon.
So an easy compromise is a legendary that changes depending on who crafts it or is selectable at the end of a quest chain like Quel'Dalar.
1h tanking mace... Warrior and Pally.
2h str tanking mace... DK
2h Agi tanking mace... Ferals
I think you are reading WAY too far into it when it comes to this subject. On top of that, we are talking about an item that Blizz probably wont even give to "Tanks" in general. Its ridiculous because Tanks don't need that kinda thing really. Maybe just give us a fancy looking epic item that looks cool and spins then we'll be happy.
---------- Post added 2011-09-14 at 10:21 AM ----------
Alright a dagger, nice. I really hope it'll be a 1.3 or 1.4 speed offhand though... It'll be a death-blow this expansion for combat spec otherwise... ... Teh gladiators is getting more and more lame, boring and just not really front page worthy. How about putting up Looking for Group for a while instead? http://www.lfgcomic.com/page/495 It at least has a STORY, and much better art.
So, hand of Ragnaros is a feral druid legendary.
Even though, at the time it dropped and was useful, it didnt have any attack rating.
Last edited by bbr; 2011-09-14 at 05:52 PM.
I really hope that thing is fake. We need legendaries that can use multiple classes. Some class-specs never had a worthy legendary before. And rogues aren't one of them.
"They might be talking about Pandas at Blizzcon."No Just No... omfg NO!
I am braziliam, sry for my english.This is ridiculous... today is very dificult get a raid (PUG), because, today is in trade: LFM BoT, link ilevel (600 minimal), and link archivement. And with new differentiation: LFM BoT, link ilevel (750 minimal), and link archievemente (dont be from LFR)... What is diferente from a LFR to a PUG ??????????? Only the form of looking for more.... Greate solution blizzard, more one racist idea. 3 ideas: 1st archievemente, 2nd ilevel, and now LFR less than normal PUG... I made many raids in WOTLK, many raids in BC, but now because i cant up more faster (work and university), and I cant do initials raids (BoT, BH, TW4 and another alphabet soup), i dont have archivements and i dont can play raid (i dont do any in cataclysm, i have 362 only from heroics).... With more this ridiculous ideia, i will like less play wow... i playing only upping any char, any realm, any class... only for fun... i doing heroics with my main only for get itens... ty and sry for my outburst.LFR tool raids will be easier than normal raids, and players will get different achievements and loot...
They should create a tank 2h that has shield powas! then all tanks are happy yaaay
---------- Post added 2011-09-14 at 09:20 PM ----------
Everyone wants a legendary in all expansion, so when it's not their class QQ is coming, and ppl want that all classes have the same amount of legendaries, but the lore has to fit in, and caster legendaries are shared by more classes, because all ranged caster dps are most likely the same. They do the same, but they got different spells(some uses more dots than others), they all uses staffs, you can give casters 1h, but i dont see a reason only if it's the only possibility to fit in lore, like illidans weps, they cant be 2h maces right..Melee dps are different, we got 1h, slow and fast, daggers even only rogues use, 2h weapons. So the group is smaller, because melee dps are more varied.
There is absolutely no way to balance the way of making legendarys that fits to multiple classes. Example the warriors had sulfuras, thunderfury, glaives, thori'dal and shadowmourne while example the enhancement shaman has nothing. I've also seen some people wanting a feral staff, but maybe you have to look a bit outside the box. The druid class just got a legendary, it wouldn't be fair if they had another one just by next patch. And they also have Fandral's Flamescythe, it might not be a legendary but it's effect is so close-up as it could possibly be. You can't satisfy everyone okay, this patch will be a rogue dagger. And rogues won't have another legendary for a very long time while the other class/spec combinations will have legendarys.