Developer Insight: Hearthsteel Virtual Currency and Housing in Midnight
Originally Posted by Blizzard (Blue Tracker / Official Forums)
Hello, everyone! We want to take a moment to discuss some of our philosophies around the shop, Hearthsteel, and our plans around Housing items acquisition.

Before diving too far in, it’s important to define what Hearthsteel is. Hearthsteel is a new virtual currency for World of Warcraft being added in the Midnight expansion. It’s purchased with real money using your Battle.net balance and used in turn to buy Housing items from the Battle.net shop and in-game shop.



Philosophy and Guiding Principles

At the top level, our main priority is making Housing fun and player-friendly, something that can be enjoyed by players of all kinds. To that end, here are a number of our guiding principles:

  • The VAST majority of Housing items are (and will continue to be) earnable in-game. Only a small fraction is available for purchase from the shop. Comparing this number against collectibles such as mounts is a good metric here, with more than a thousand mounts earnable in-game and only a few dozen from the shop.
  • Housing items tied to core fantasies of a player’s race or class, or that already exist in Azeroth, won’t be sold in the shop. Thematically important decor that players know and love will also not appear in the shop.
  • All Housing items in the shop will be available for individual purchase. While we’ll sometimes offer sales on bundles of items for a limited time, you shouldn’t feel like you have to spend money NOW or risk missing something you want.
  • Costs in the shop are clearly defined. The ratios of Hearthsteel to real money are fixed and easily understood at a glance. You should be able to obtain an amount that makes sense for the purchases you want to make.
  • Similarly, the costs of items are designed to align with Hearthsteel offer amounts in a player-friendly way. Buying Hearthsteel at the amount you want lets you purchase the items you want without requiring you to think about which packs should be added together to minimize leftovers.
  • The shop User Interface (UI) is straight-forward and easy to understand.
  • Hearthsteel should integrate cleanly into the existing Battle.net economy. This means not just being able to purchase it in-game, on the web, or in the launcher, but it should also be compatible with the normal flow of the WoW Token, letting you earn gold in game and then use that gold to ultimately purchase Hearthsteel via the WoW Token.
  • Hearthsteel is for Housing. We currently have no plans to use it for the Trading Post, mounts, transmogs, or pets.



Why a Virtual Currency?

This was one of the first things we heard the community discussing. Why bother when we already have a Battle.net balance? It’s important to note that when dealing in transactions involving real money, a more deliberate and cautious process needs to be implemented to provide appropriate financial protections for both parties. This can be an inefficient, inconvenient, and often tedious process when a player wants to purchase multiple items.

Smaller Housing items in the shop are often low cost and players will want to purchase multiples of them to complete a set. As an example, you may want a full set of chairs to place around a dining table, multiple place settings for your invited guests, or even many candles to help decorate the room for a complete look. Using an in-game currency can help make the process of obtaining many of these types of inexpensive items more efficient.



Housing Catalog


You may have already seen hints of this on the alpha or Public Test Realm (PTR), but we’re adding a Housing Catalog to the Housing UI, which allows players to view all potential Housing decor (earnable, purchasable, special promotions, and so on). It lets you not only preview it in the UI but also place a temporary version in your home as well, so you can see how it fits in before deciding if you want to spend time tracking it down or purchasing it from the shop.



Wrapping Up

We’ve said it before and we’ll keep saying it, but please keep your feedback coming. We’re so excited to continue to share more about the future of Housing in the coming weeks and months.
This article was originally published in forum thread: Developer Insight: Hearthsteel Virtual Currency and Housing in Midnight started by Lumy View original post
Comments 149 Comments
  1. MoMedic's Avatar
    This just in! Capitalistic company operating in a capitalistic system earns money through capitalism! Lock the china cabinet and hide the buttermilk grandpa!!! Them varmints at Blizzard are after your monies!
  1. RobertMugabe's Avatar
    Damn the haters were right.
  1. Nerph-'s Avatar
    Quote Originally Posted by MoMedic View Post
    This just in! Capitalistic company operating in a capitalistic system earns money through capitalism! Lock the china cabinet and hide the buttermilk grandpa!!! Them varmints at Blizzard are after your monies!
    oops yeah I forgot saying this suddenly makes it alright. Thanks! <3
  1. Cheezits's Avatar
    Housing items tied to core fantasies of a player’s race or class, or that already exist in Azeroth, won’t be sold in the shop. Thematically important decor that players know and love will also not appear in the shop.
    As you can see the shop housing items are all cozycore dream stuff that was not going to be put into the game any other way, as it isn't based off anything that exists in the game. I'll start getting mad when they put NPC race stuff in the store (ie Revendreth themed exterior style).
  1. RobertMugabe's Avatar
    Quote Originally Posted by Vladar View Post
    Dont really care about housing, I will have a low effort house and thats enough. No way I will ever spend cash on housing items, its even more ridiculous than spending money on a digital mount.
    Same. ngl I always wanted housing in WoW, but now that we actually have it, I kinda just don't really care, even though the system is better than anything I'd have imagined.

    Like it sounds cool and everything, but in practice I feel like this will be just a thing where I will spend 2-3 hours to make something decent and after that I'll just get bored of doing anything to it. Maybe I will AFK there from time to time, but other than that, what's the point? I doubt many people will actively do stuff with it and RP there (already a small niche even on RP servers lmao).

    This feature will be dead-ish for like 90% of the entire playerbase after a few weeks and it'll only be something for content creators and reddit karma farmers.
  1. fatgunn's Avatar
    Quote Originally Posted by Cheezits View Post
    As you can see the shop housing items are all cozycore dream stuff that was not going to be put into the game any other way, as it isn't based off anything that exists in the game. I'll start getting mad when they put NPC race stuff in the store (ie Revendreth themed exterior style).
    Exactly this. half the stuff you're gonna be able to buy with Hearthsteel will probably be plushies.
  1. Cheezits's Avatar
    Quote Originally Posted by fatgunn View Post
    Exactly this. half the stuff you're gonna be able to buy with Hearthsteel will probably be plushies.
    It is 100% going to be primarily cutesy stuff that barely fits into Warcraft, but the target demographic for that kind of stuff does not care. Probably kitty cats, faeries, angels etc. Just like the love witch outfit.

    I'll eat my hat if they change it up but I feel like the first year of items will predominantly be that + maybe crossover themed items.
  1. Reive's Avatar
    Quote Originally Posted by fatgunn View Post
    Exactly this. half the stuff you're gonna be able to buy with Hearthsteel will probably be plushies.
    Quote Originally Posted by Cheezits View Post
    It is 100% going to be primarily cutesy stuff that barely fits into Warcraft, but the target demographic for that kind of stuff does not care. Probably kitty cats, faeries, angels etc. Just like the love witch outfit.

    I'll eat my hat if they change it up but I feel like the first year of items will predominantly be that + maybe crossover themed items.
    pls don't defend this. premium currencies shouldn't be a thing
  1. Daedius's Avatar
    Purchased base game that requires a subscription, an online store on top of that already. And they want to add a premium currency?!

    Yeeeeah I'm done with WoW, going to send in my refund request with Midnight.

    Done funding this greedy as FUCK company. More so when they've the audacity to have all these stuff pile up [annual sub 12 Month mount, shop items practically every month, pre-order, etc.] when the game is the buggiest it's ever been.

    Already screams prelude to a F2P model, and I loathe F2P games. MS/Blizz is just milking whatever remnant of players are left playing for all they're worth.
  1. fatgunn's Avatar
    Quote Originally Posted by Reive View Post
    pls don't defend this. premium currencies shouldn't be a thing
    Buy what you want, don't buy the rest. Other people's lack of self control isn't my problem.
  1. Cheezits's Avatar
    Quote Originally Posted by Reive View Post
    pls don't defend this. premium currencies shouldn't be a thing
    Not defending it, just saying it does not upset me, especially as I do not see the difference between a premium currency and a candle being $0.50 battle net balance. People would hate both.

    When they start locking things I care about to the shop then I will have an issue.
  1. Daronokk's Avatar
    Quote Originally Posted by MoMedic View Post
    This just in! Capitalistic company operating in a capitalistic system earns money through capitalism! Lock the china cabinet and hide the buttermilk grandpa!!! Them varmints at Blizzard are after your monies!
    There is a clear distinction between regular capitalism and predatory monetization. Don't be such a fanboy and protect the corpos like that.
  1. Hitei's Avatar
    Quote Originally Posted by Cheezits View Post
    It is 100% going to be primarily cutesy stuff that barely fits into Warcraft, but the target demographic for that kind of stuff does not care. Probably kitty cats, faeries, angels etc. Just like the love witch outfit.

    I'll eat my hat if they change it up but I feel like the first year of items will predominantly be that + maybe crossover themed items.
    I don't know why you'd assume it'll be primarily cutesy.

    It occupies the exact same detached design space as the trading post or actual b.net shop, which means it will also feature the same sort of non-cutesy but not exactly flush with setting items. You should expect to see cutesy stuff but also things like the phoenix or venetian solar transmog, or the grizzly hills bear, or the mecha drake mount.
  1. Ghostile's Avatar
    Damn blizzard, monetizing housing was all fine and dandy before you did it! How could you?!
  1. Hitei's Avatar
    Quote Originally Posted by Daedius View Post
    Purchased base game that requires a subscription, an online store on top of that already. And they want to add a premium currency?!

    Yeeeeah I'm done with WoW, going to send in my refund request with Midnight.

    Done funding this greedy as FUCK company. More so when they've the audacity to have all these stuff pile up [annual sub 12 Month mount, shop items practically every month, pre-order, etc.] when the game is the buggiest it's ever been.

    Already screams prelude to a F2P model, and I loathe F2P games. MS/Blizz is just milking whatever remnant of players are playing for all they're worth.
    See you in 3 months.
  1. Cheezits's Avatar
    Quote Originally Posted by Hitei View Post
    I don't know why you'd assume it'll be primarily cutesy.
    Target audience + demographics + first two shop bundles being datamined are plushies and spring fairy furniture straight out of Pixie Hollow.

    If we get a big flaming Garrosh statue I'll come back and apologize.
  1. Berz3rk's Avatar
    So i wonder, what's the point of housing at all? You're gonna log there and afk sitting on a chair or what?
  1. Trazzle's Avatar
    Doomers will doom.

    Who cares? Absolutely no one should be shocked by this, the biggest way most players will interact with hearthsteel will likely be via game purchase bundles, “buy the heroic their or above and receive 5k hearthsteel!”. People who don’t have the time available to grind/put time into the game but still want a flashy house now have an option (one that makes more money for bliz of course).

    Where/when the line’s crossed, if hearthsteel’s the only way to get exclusive/“the best looking” items. Both of which, it’s too early to know (I’m sure it’ll happen but to what degree is to be seen).

    I’d rather not doom, housing has been implemented incredibly well, blizzard further milking it/lining their pockets off their work, par for the course… it’s a business after all. (With all the purchase options… would sure be slick if they eased off the monthly sub…)
  1. Hitei's Avatar
    Quote Originally Posted by Cheezits View Post
    Target audience + demographics + first two shop bundles being datamined are plushies and spring fairy furniture straight out of Pixie Hollow.

    If we get a big flaming Garrosh statue I'll come back and apologize.
    The first item on the shop-shop was the sparkle pony... which was then followed up by the big flaming horns/skeletal crown/spooky dark portal hood transmog helms.
  1. Illuminance's Avatar
    The Virtual Currency argument they use as damage control is so stupid it's an insult to the players' intelligence. If you are buying a table and chairs (virtual or not), it's much easier to understand if the purchase is in $USD (or your respective local currency) than some contrived housing ducats.

Site Navigation