Rate The Rogue Above You.

[Pareidolia]

Lets see what people think I can improve on.

http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...i%C3%A1/simple

Always up for constructive criticism.

With the following reforges, you can get a little more hit without being over cap and a little more expertise which should *theoretically* get you some extra deeps.

Removed reforge from Bladeshadow Wristguards
Removed reforge from Blackfang Battleweave Tunic
Reforged Blackfang Battleweave Gloves to -94 Expertise Rating / +94 Haste Rating
Reforged Blackfang Battleweave Helmet to -110 Crit Rating / +110 Mastery Rating
Removed reforge from Windslicer Boomerang
Removed reforge from Cameo of Terrible Memories
Reforged Belt of Hidden Keys to -99 Mastery Rating / +99 Expertise Rating
Removed reforge from Molten Blood Footpads
Reforged Golad, Twilight of Aspects to -62 Crit Rating / +62 Expertise Rating
Reforged Signet of Grasping Mouths to -71 Crit Rating / +71 Mastery Rating
Reforged Underdweller's Spaulders to -96 Mastery Rating / +96 Expertise Rating

Since it looks like you're currently still running Firelands content, you should aim to pick up the Dreadfire Drape from heroic Rhyolith.
As far as gems go, epics! Epics! I know they're sometimes expensive, but hopefully not completely out of reach.

I would say 7.5/10 assuming you don't have a reason for reforging the way you are. If you do, 8.5 based on gems / progression. Looks like you're of the best in your guild (get a new one >_>).

I'm curious as to what people say of me now. Finally got enough gold to gem up everything.
http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...raeil/advanced

[Goldlink]

I'm curious as to what people say of me now. Finally got enough gold to gem up everything.
http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...raeil/advanced

I'd go with ehh... a 9/10...
You leveling engineering but don't use the glove enchant?
And the only other thing i'd complain about is the ring gem.. Why the lava coral when you can get 15 more agi with another Queen's Garnet?

http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...ickle/advanced
I was enchanted mainly for sub progression (on heroic spine), so don't complain too much about the reforges <3

[Agatha]

I'd go with ehh... a 9/10...
You leveling engineering but don't use the glove enchant?
And the only other thing i'd complain about is the ring gem.. Why the lava coral when you can get 15 more agi with another Queen's Garnet?

http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...ickle/advanced
I was enchanted mainly for sub progression (on heroic spine), so don't complain too much about the reforges <3

9/10
Oh oh oh... good transmog!
Also, very nice gems everywhere :3
I'm a little jealous because you have DAT trinket (Heroic Vial)
I think your enchants and reforges are okay (Though I'd use 65 Mastery for gloves), and the only part of your gear I'd change is the cloak, a couple FL runs every now and then could get you that great cloak.

That's it, grats on your legendaries

Link to my armory in my sig :3

[kilj]

You look like me 9/10 nothing much to say

[Goldlink]

9/10
Oh oh oh... good transmog!
Also, very nice gems everywhere :3
I'm a little jealous because you have DAT trinket (Heroic Vial)
I think your enchants and reforges are okay (Though I'd use 65 Mastery for gloves), and the only part of your gear I'd change is the cloak, a couple FL runs every now and then could get you that great cloak.

That's it, grats on your legendaries

Link to my armory in my sig :3

Ty for the transmog compliment <3 It was the bloodfang for the longest time.. when i was a gobby.. then when i went female belf I was like "Oo, time to make her look like a slut" xD

Gems - Ya.. fucking went broke buying them :B
About the gloves - Ya, I forgot to swap it back to mastery.. I was trying combat with stacking crit instead of mastery, so thats why I have the haste on there..
Cloak - Lawl, good luck finding a competent group on my server who could do H FL :P

Danke <3

As for you Mr. Kilj...

9/10
Get rid of that helm and buy the VP one.. 2nd BIS for combat (#1 being Tier Helm), besides.. 4 set SUCKS for combat.
Other thing would be... get rid of alchemy.. Pick up JC with Blacksmithing <3
Dat is all.

http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...ickle/advanced

[kilj]

Alchemy? I got engineering...... also im going to replace 397 with 410 tier hopefully this week :P

Ty for the transmog compliment <3 It was the bloodfang for the longest time.. when i was a gobby.. then when i went female belf I was like "Oo, time to make her look like a slut" xD

Gems - Ya.. fucking went broke buying them :B
About the gloves - Ya, I forgot to swap it back to mastery.. I was trying combat with stacking crit instead of mastery, so thats why I have the haste on there..
Cloak - Lawl, good luck finding a competent group on my server who could do H FL :P

Danke <3

As for you Mr. Kilj...

9/10
Get rid of that helm and buy the VP one.. 2nd BIS for combat (#1 being Tier Helm), besides.. 4 set SUCKS for combat.
Other thing would be... get rid of alchemy.. Pick up JC with Blacksmithing <3
Dat is all.

http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...ickle/advanced

[Goldlink]

where the fuck did i see alchemy then? x.x My bad lol

[Pareidolia]

I'd go with ehh... a 9/10...
You leveling engineering but don't use the glove enchant?
And the only other thing i'd complain about is the ring gem.. Why the lava coral when you can get 15 more agi with another Queen's Garnet?

http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...ickle/advanced
I was enchanted mainly for sub progression (on heroic spine), so don't complain too much about the reforges <3

No, definitely using the glove enchant. That's the only reason I'm an engineer.

15 agi vs 25 haste... According to shadowcraft haste is worth 1.96 ep vs 2.87 for agi.

49 ep vs 43.05

Haste beats it out, not by much mind you, but it's also nice that I don't have to spend the extra gold.

[Deleted]

Dno who to rate here atm due to spam

eu.battle.net/wow/en/character/dragonblight/Kaleria/advanced

[kilj]

1/10 for no heroic neck <3333 I kid I kid.

9/10 looks good just missing a few for full BiS

[thunderclese]

9/10 Not much to improve really. No tinker on your back, but not a huge deal

us.battle.net/wow/en/character/earthen-ring/Thunderclese/advanced

[Deleted]

Thunderclese:

Dem epic gemz! + I'm curious as to why you've chosen Blade Twisting over Imp. Sprint.

[Deleted]

10/10 just because you have that god damn ring >_<

my armory in my signature. I'm most likely in the hemo sub spec/reforges since I'm bored. Got No'kaled heroic for Combat since I'm 3 weeks off my legendaries :<

[Msi]

-MoP Edition-

I will start first:

http://eu.battle.net/wow/en/characte...us/Msii/simple

[Coldkil]

not going over 7/10, since raids aren't still opened. My armory is on sig - still starting to gather gear but with the hotfix i should be able to enter heroics already today.

[kilj]

You are definately on the right track cold, keep at it here's mine http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...Kakashi/simple

[Deleted]

8/10

Golden Lotus/Tillers rep seems pretty far behind, guess you missed a day or so which is going to end up hurting you later.
Passive enchants on cloak/boots, imo ignore MrRobot when it comes to it suggesting passive enchants as when switching from combat - assassination mid raid your reforge will be the only thing you'll want to change and you might end up cock blocking your reforge with them.
Other than that gogo belt buckle, perfect cut gems, normal mode and trash farm!

http://eu.battle.net/wow/en/characte...s/Nik/advanced

Getting a bit nervous about tonights raids, at current it's 3 raid groups and loads of trash All I seem to want to do is get more Spirits to craft my LW'ing gloves and try to perfect my gear when I really shouldn't

[NonMagical]

Let's see. Budget shoulder enchant. Your gems seem wrong (if I am not mistaken, Combat prioritizes haste over mastery, so your gems should be Deft (agi/haste). I can't imagine your boot enchant is best for PvE (At least, I wouldn't take 175 haste over 140 agi + movement speed, not even for Combat). Need to replace your Direbrew trinket with a heroic 463 trinket.

Outside of gear... Reputations look good. Professions good. Nice PvP ratings. Glyphs seem fine.

Just minor tweaks all in all. 8/10

====================

#4 most geared Rogue in the world according to wowprogress. Weeeeeeee.

http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...cigam/advanced

I know I have the budget leg enchant, but on AH they are going for 10k and I can't afford that. :/ Also glyphs and such are for dailies.