Originally Posted by
Laurix
I'm pretty much going to explain this once, because everyone seems to be hopping on the "Monks are worthless" train far too often.
-Monks are balanced overall, but they need some fine-tuning that should have been resolved from beta -> live. Windwalker doesn't gain enough from speccing Windwalker, and we have two abilties that might as well be thrown off our bars (JCL and Path of Blossums).
-Most high-end arena players rolled with what they have been the past three expansions (minus the Rogues, since Rogues suck -- IE Reckful; Neilyo)
-The general consensus by the overall community is Monks absolutely suck in every way. This is wrong.
-The general consensus by many of the high-rated arena players (Tich specifically) is they're decent. They can lock someone down with great control, and have CONSTANT GOOD pressure, unlike Rogues, Ret's, and Warrior's outside of CD's. Feral and DK can match (and out-perform depending on comp) constant pressure, but Monk is definitely up there.
-Monks are only weak because of their vulnerability to Fears/Stuns. I don't agree with a fear-break, because almost everyone has one, but we need to be able to use a CD while stunned. Or a new defensive CD all together.
-Monks are strong, if not one of THE BEST duelists (1v1). That said, the value of Monk depreciates the bigger the group. 2v2 they're great (like 2v2 matters, I know), 3v3 they're decent. 5v5? Worthless. Can they be replaced with a Warrior? Absolutely (in their current broken state). Other than that, they do have some niche rolls they can fill. They can peel, self-heal, and control very well.
-There aren't many level 90 Monks still, most serious PvP'ers didn't bother, most serious PvE'ers didn't bother, and the fact that everyone and their grandmother is cheesing the brackets playing KFC/God Comp is why you don't see too many Monks (..Or DK's, Rogues, Rets, DPS Shamans). The ladders are stacked with Hunter, Warrior, Mage, SPriest.
-Everyone knew DK was going to be OP. DK's started at 55, so everyone and anyone leveled one. Hero class, remember? The combination of the Season 5 fiasco, leveling from 1 (non-hero class), and people not wanting to be a test subject all expansion is why you don't see that many Monks. And truthfully, whoever played the beta knew the class had some glaring problems, especially Windwalker. Blizzard was too ignorant to listen, is going to take 6 months to realize it, but regardless they did SOME things right, because the spec is definitely still viable. If anything, I'm 100x more worried about them in PvE than PvP. No cleaves, no 'execute phase', worthless mastery, poor scaling. Yeah...