Originally Posted by
Shaoshi
ok, prot pally here,
first off, yes you are being a bit childish, however, we all are at sometime, perhaps indeed it was a better upgrade, i for one got the scimitar from a coin, which made me happy and my OT pissed off XD.
the best enchant for Prot pala's right now is windsong, this because our itemization is totally skewed compared to wrath or cata, its like this
Hit 7.5% exp 15% ( yes FULL 15) Haste->mastery->parry->dodge->crit. since the weapon has hit and mastery and a socket its incredibly useful.
also, the sha touched weapon normal version is for some reason, 40 hit and mastery better, on the same Ilvl, so wait till you get that.
if you're already beating enrage timers, albeit only just, then pure gear is no longer a problem, the last boss that will give you enrage issues on normal should be garalon/wind lord mel'jarak.
so yes, you may have had better use of it, since just about all prot pala gear has hit on it, and few pieces expertise, so that would make elegion better itemized, but still less in overall stats.
unless you think you will never get screwed over on loot in another guild, your better off discussing with the GM and the officers to reserve Kilrak for you and youll be much better off.
good luck