I understand and agree with the OP.
I "quit" GW2 about a month ago. Since I come from DAoC and a lot of employees at A-Net are from Mythic I really expected a little more out of WvW which was the main reason I bought GW2.
Maps way to small, destroying keep walls and doors from the tower next to it by just putting up a trebuchet? uhm no thanks, to easy to claim keeps, towers, supply camps, to hard to defend them.
Hoping for a "new frontiers" hehe but I doubt it will ever happen. And I have to admit, I didn't think it would bother me in the long run but it did, I missed the trinity (a lot).