While on the Isle of Thunder i've come across many players of the opposite faction who have PVP disabled, they're unattackable and their names show up in blue, as if they were in a home city.
There's also this one hunter on my server, a known pest who's been griefing the Isle non-stop since day one and he can disable PVP and make himself unattackable in the middle of a fight...
Anyone have any ideas what's going on here? And yes, this IS a PVP server.