Originally Posted by
shoegazing
They made the decision in Legion to make sweeping redesign of classes and specs, splitting up the Rogue specs to each feel "more unique".
I have mained a Rogue since 2004. I didn't main Subtlety, Assassination, or Outlaw, I see myself as first and foremost a Rogue however none of the new specs feels like a Rogue any longer. Each has taken some piece of it and amplified that, while forgetting over a decade of design and polish and the core Rogue fantasy at its roots.
Take Subtlety for example, which despite my overall loyalty to the class first and foremost, was always my favorite spec. Shadow Dance used to be one of the most exciting abilities in the game, because it was a powerful cooldown that allowed you to use your opening moves outside of Stealth. This could increase your burst damage by a lot, but it was also extremely useful for the utility, particularly so in PvP. What Blizzard did was they decided Shadow Dance is going to the basis of the spec now, the core of its rotation. On paper this may even sound like a good idea, but in practice it is absolute garbage. First, they deleted half of the opening moves that we could use while Dancing, so now it's really just a vehicle for spamming three buttons. Yes it happens more often, but it's not exciting when it happens, it's just a mundane piece of the rotation. Second, they deleted all of the core Rogue flavor that exists outside of Shadow Dance.... now it's just the entire spec.
I say this as someone who loved Shadow Dance, it's my favorite button in the game. New Subtlety Rogue is based entirely around Shadow Dance, and I fucking hate it. This is a trashed version of the masterpiece that I loved for over a decade.
The actual ClassFantasyTM itself is extremely cringe, hamfisted, and derpy. All of the actual Subtlety is gone, all the sneaky trickery replaced with gaudy purple particle effects, meanwhile I have no poisons, no bleeds, I don't have Gouge which I'd had keybound on the same button (my "4" key) for well over a decade. This isn't a Rogue, I fucking hate everything that they've done to my character, and that's why my subscription is canceled.
- - - Updated - - -
How about instead of removing abilities and slowing the game down to try to dumb it down for bad PvPers they let the bad PvPers grow and learn -- just like every good PvPer had to do in order to learn to play.