Originally Posted by
NabyBro
What people don't seem to understand is that Zandalari warlocks were a thing during the 1 year period before blizzcon (and even ON blizzcon) while paladins were not, and were only switched because Blizz saw an opportunity at giving the horde another paladin race, even tho they perfectly explained why zandalari paladins were not going to be a thing with Rezan being dead and prelates losing their main source of worship.
But let's tackle this from another angle.
Technically, every playable race COULD be every playable class as far as "this tauren learned how to use arcane magic" and stuff.
BUT,
Playable race-class combinations are related to the in-universe culture of any given race. That's why tauren mages are not a thing, because the tauren culture does not work with the arcane and other mage stuff.
There are only 2 classes that make literally no sense in this regard: Monks and Warlocks.
Monks are the "we learned this from pandas" class. They are basically ex-whatever class that switched to the Monk way via training. That's why i think only pandas should be monks (like only elves can be Dh's) but whatever, it's what it is now.
Warlocks however are not accepted in almost any society or culture.
Humans, dwarves, gnomes, worgen, dark iron, orcs, trolls, blood elves and the nightborne all oppose "warlocks" and the fel in the traditional terms.
Out of these races the only 3 that were related to any demon activities are orcs, blood elves and the nightborne.
Orcs are the only race in-game that are given a lore reason why they can exist by Thrall literally stating he knows they're bad, but they're needed so they can stay in the drag.
Blood elves and the nightborne being warlocks go heavily against their established hatred for the Burning Legion and demons in general.
Goblins just simply don't care which is fine. Undead are culturally open to any kind of dark magic which is also fine.
Trolls are the only race out of these that can use the 'tauren paladin' excuse, which is "they are only warlocks as a class, but in game they are witch doctors/hexxers" and are not referred to as warlocks, which is actually pretty accurate because you never see a darkspear warlock anywhere in-game.
Void Elves are a narrative catastrophe, i won't comment on those.
The rest of the races plainly should not even be able to be a Warlock, as they had no previous contact with demons or the Burning Legion which is the exact same argument used against the Zandalari warlocks.
Here comes the twister: maybe being a Warlock is not even based on the fel or demon stuff?
Yes, they can summon demons for gameplay reasons as a pet class, but if you actually look at a warlocks arsenal they have fire, shadow and death magic at their hands.
None of which is associated with the fel necessarily, but more like forbidden spells/magic that are shunned by normal mages.
If we use this logic we can see how alliance race warlocks make sense in the game. They are former casters who started dwelling in the forbidden arts.
Which is pretty solid, as that is why they are not allowed into society and are forced to hide their magic/powers.
If we see warlocks this way, we can see how Zandalari warlocks make crazy amounts of sense. Almost none of the warlock races (except goblins and undead) allow warlocks into their 'culture' or allow them to roam in their main cities, they force them to hide and stuff. Zandalari would do the same.
But also, the zandalari are the most versatile race there is on Azeroth: they are the oldest and they have witnessed everything that we know about as far as lore goes: old gods, 2 Burning Legion invasions, death, arcane, light, druidism, shamanism, whatever there is by simply being the most ancient race. A zandalari can learn and master whatever they set out to be.
So by this logic it's only evident having Zandlari warlocks is normal, either going the demon route (undead, goblin) or the witch doctor route (darkspear trolls).
The argument that there are no Zandalari warlocks walking around Dazar'alor is flawed in every aspect:
Blizzard saying that they had no contact with the fel is simply impossible: the Zandalari survived TWO Burning Legion invasions, the second one supposedly being global.
Simply by seeing how easily zandalari citizens convert to G'huun, it is not hard to imagine lots of zandalari actually joining the Burning Legion or learning about them to survive. They have an affinity with dealing in dark magics be it blood, death, voodoo and whatever.
Secondly, if you go into any major city you won't find Warlocks, worst offender here is Gilneas and the Worgen warlocks as their culture had literally nothing to do with neither the dark arts nor demons. The worgen curse is druidic in nature.
So there are two options that need to be more defined so that people can accept why the zandalari can't be warlocks:
Option A) is that being a warlock is a learnt thing and every race should be able to be one.
Option B) is to define what a warlock is in a society, what their role is in the culture and why that doesn't align with the zandalari and others like the tauren, because as of right now not many races have a clear reason to even support such a "class" in their culture unlike every other class.