She's not winning. No one's winning. I've said this once, and I'll say it again. The Player Characters win, always. Even when they lose, they win. Simple. Argus and Arthas proved that much.
She's not winning. No one's winning. I've said this once, and I'll say it again. The Player Characters win, always. Even when they lose, they win. Simple. Argus and Arthas proved that much.
The bait was the "amg she's evil and we alllllll know it"
- - - Updated - - -
Alliance started the war....
Desolate Council had numerous traitors and she didn't have time to sit and interrogate each one
The Horde she killed were already about to die had she not done it and resurrecting them helped other Horde not die so not sure where you were going
Even if you were to assume it was a trap, sometimes you need to send troops into a trap if them succeeding outweighs them getting trapped.
I honestly hope you're never in charge of even a family.
- - - Updated - - -
Yogg'Saron? You mean the one who was at war with the dead because he COULDN'T and they were on his land harvesting his blood? Oh wait and the undead who had a faceless one chained up in a cave using him? Wow if only he could mind control them...
Old Gods canonically CANNOT manipulate or control the dead. It was a part of Arthas's plan.
I dont think Sylvanas wins.
But you could say... the Horde wins.
Cause i think she will be defeated and flee away, in order to be the main villain in a future expansion.
I think Thrall or maybe Baine will be warchief.
Sad thing is, Alliance is still stuck with Anduin.
Does not matter if they are for Sylvanas. Thing is most of her 'win scenario's' pretty much end WoW assuming it includes her staying warchief. Not because the 'horde wins'. But because I and likely am not the only one, have no trust in blizzard writing any expansion where alliance is as good as destroyed and the horde taking over most of the world, or what is left of it. That really is stuff for a new rts, not for a 2 faction mmo.
I'm an altoholic since 2005.
I could definitely go for some big castles and succubines.
Anduin will absolve Sylvanas of her sins and they will join the Alliance and the Horde with a political marriage.
She won't.
Good guys always wins at the end. It's story-telling 101, and no writer has ever successfully deviated from that, ever, with a few exceptions being Empire Strikes Back and Watchmen. Those stories were written by superior writers however, and Blizzard is a video game company dabbling in 2-dimensional story-telling.
Sylvanas may not be forced out of the Horde so they can say she wasn't Garrosh, so she might outright abandon the Horde and run off to the Shadowlands because she got what she wanted, or what she wants is there.
That's what I want to happen, I want a clear winner. It doesn't have to be the Horde, but I want someone to win, someone to do something BIG like the War of Thorns and Battle of Lordaeron or The Battle For Undercity or even Rejection of the Gift by Illidan. Something like that to shake the playerbase and make us say "holy shit" because those events, those moments are still some of the best story beats Warcraft has EVER reached in my opinion.
And we have been at constant stalemates, constant tension, constant battles since ever. I would like to see a side Win. I as Horde player wouldn't be upset if the Alliance win...it would be interesting to see where they would take the story, how things would develop after.
Last edited by Evaddon; 2019-04-24 at 07:24 PM.
Dickmann's Law: As a discussion on the Lore forums becomes longer, the probability of the topic derailing to become about Sylvanas approaches 1.
Tinkers will be the next Class confirmed.
Well not quite. If Argus wipes us, the Pantheon and Azeroth both fall and we're completely screwed. Currently we're only mostly screwed, which is the best kind of situation since it means we have a 1% chance of not being screwed, which by narrative causality means we're actually not screwed at all.
All that said, Sylvanas is done for sure. Unless the rebellion gets called off and Sylvie is somehow gracious with the rebels (lol), it's her, her boytoy and mayyybe Gallywix against the leaders of the Orcs, Trolls, Taurens, Blood Elves + Rexxar and Thrall (not counting Allied Race leaders, which is doing Sylvie a favor as only Not-Thrall has expressed any kind of support for her). There's only one way this ends, and it's not with 70% of the Horde's cast executed or in chains. What the Horde's people want is completely and utterly irrelevant because Warcraft is almost entirely character-driven.
The only question that remains is if Sylvie bites it or escapes to plot more villainous schemes. I'd bet on the latter, sadly, but her dying in BFA's final moments could also happen. But the hardest thing to determine then is who gets the kill, given that there's tons and tons of people clamoring for her head now.