Originally Posted by
Kagthul
Both are a serious step down from the X10, other than AX-support.
I guess my question would be...
in what was is the X10 R9000 not doing what you need it to do?
If it is doing everything you need it to do.... i see no point in buying something newer. You're not likely to need Wifi6 (AX) compatability for years, as devices that natively support it are JUST starting to come out.
If you MUST replace it for whatever reason, youll want to look for a device that has several antennas and the ability to assign them to individual SSIDs - keep your smart devices on one SSID so they dont interfere with/slow down your other SSID... and hard-wire everything you can.
Get an additional Gigabit Switch if you need to (you can get unmanaged ones - which is all you should need as a residential user - for pretty cheap) and hardwire everything its possible to hardwire.
Limit devices that are below Wifi 5 to one SSID, and Wifi 5+ to another (thatll keep the faster devices from being slowed down by that one device that is still running Wirless-N or some shit).
Honestly, i've got 25+ devices on my home network and im using a "lowly" Nighthawk RAX40 (AX4) including a ton of smart bulbs (7), switches (8) Google Home Mini's (7), a Google Home Hub, several tablets, 2 chromebooks, a Surface Go, 2 Roku's, and 2-4 phones (i actually dont connect mine to the network since we have unlimited data and i dont care, but my wife and son do). And thats not even counting the wired stuff (the Roku Ultra, QNAP NAS, HTPC, 3 Gaming PCs (mine, my wifes, my sons), 2 daily-driver Macs (mine and my wifes), Steamlink, TV.
And i had all that connected to the much older "original" Nighthawk (R7000), before a series of rapid power spikes cooked it (it was the only thing not plugged into the conditioned power bar, since the brick wouldn't fit), and that worked just fine.