Originally Posted by
Val the Moofia Boss
People hated SGU because it wasn't Stargate.
Stargate is fun, light hearted action adventure story about modern soldiers romping through a space opera.
SGU wasn't that. It was a brooding, nihilistic story about everybody being cramped on board a horror spaceship. Everybody hates each other. Hardly anyone in the cast is unlikable. We hardly get to explore new worlds, only seeing glimpses of aliens from afar and never getting to interact with their culture.
Imagine if the Star Trek TNG reboot wasn't TOS 2.0, but a horror story in space.
That's what happened with SGU. That's why SG1 and SGA fans rejected it.
A Stargate reboot can be good. It just has to actually be Stargate. Then again, MGM has monkey's for brains.