Originally Posted by
lappee
There is no data about those situations on your part either, only things you have data on is the ST and MT sims that last 4-6 mins - which I already said Venthyr is the best for.
Like, do I really need to run a sim that lasts for 10 sec to see which is better? Because that is really obvious from every angle, in such burst situation Night Fae wins pretty much regardless of number of targets (though there likely is a breakpoint where Venthyr casting just plain Starfire wins).
You want me no numerically prove something that is logically obvious, yet you don't have any numbers either and claim to be correct because "but maaam, smart people think like me!" - not a very compelling way to introduce yourself.
You were whining about New Moon being bad, only being used in one build that is 800 dps behind the top build. Yet when looking at the data aka sims new moon is 150 dps behind the best comp (where most difference is from our top Legendary being bad for it, as I explained earlier in this thread) and 60 dps behind when that "broken" legendary is taken out of the picture. Yes, FoE is still the best but the row is rather balanced already and if it went live this way then there really wouldn't be any issues with it as you could play any of them in ST - preferably they'd buff moons by a tiny bit to make it better in ST and FoE while FoE reigns in AoE (or just reduce Full moon AoE reduction to make it competitive in AoE).
With current tuning most hardcore PvE players will pick Venthyr, no questions about it but claiming it is the best in every situation is just blatantly false.