Mafia Monster Mash

[Firebert]

Someone is very likely to be eliminated during the night phase, which puts us down to ten - nine if Dupti is lying and there are, in fact, more vampires than he says there are.

Best possible scenario for the Vampires is N1 Mark, N2 Turn, N3 Mark. Either Robo or Dupti were turned, and Robo got Witched, so there are still at maximum two Vamps. They can grab their third tonight, but not NK (as the Wolves are extremely likely to block the double-bite).

The worst possible scenario for the Vampires is that each time the Elder has marked a target they've subsequently been NKed or Lynched, and Dupti is the Elder and pretending to be a Fledgling under the guise that he cannot vote.

[Graeham]

Unvote
Vote: Bwom

To put my money where my mouth is. I'll switch over to Dupti to secure a lynch if needed, but I don't fancy a complete blind stab in the dark.

[Firebert]

Unvote

Vote: Bwonsamdi

It's interesting to note that when Catta and Marack are suggested as alternative trains, Bwonsamdi immediately hops off the Marack train, and I have them as scumbuddies.

- - - Updated - - -

I have them as scumbuddies.

That is, Bwonsamdi and Marack.

- - - Updated - - -

Bwonsamdi and Catta at 3, Xanjori and Dupti at 2, 5.5h remain.

[LemonDemonGirl]

Shit....

What's with everyone thinking I'm Scum?

[Crackleslap]

My god this is a mess.

[Omertocracy]

Shit....

What's with everyone thinking I'm Scum?

At this point in the game, guaranteed at least one vote on you is scum looking to hide.

I leave at the hour to go play D&D, won't be back until after day ends. Will adjust my vote before then.

[Catta]

In the interest of not getting lynched i can switch to Bwon too but id much rather just lynch Xan

[Crackleslap]

Shit....

What's with everyone thinking I'm Scum?

Whats your read or opinion on Graeham & Marack. Do you think they're human/wolf/vampire?

[Firebert]

My god this is a mess.

A tale for the ages!

[LemonDemonGirl]

Whats your read or opinion on Graeham & Marack. Do you think they're human/wolf/vampire?

I'd say they're probably likely to be either vampires/wolves

Marack said he's a human before so I think he's (probably) safe

[Crackleslap]

In the interest of not getting lynched i can switch to Bwon too but id much rather just lynch Xan

I lowkey don't like the bwon lynch. Even if she is scum, I kinda feel like its way to easy to just pile on the new player.

[Firebert]

I'd say they're probably likely to be either vampires/wolves

Marack said he's a human before so I think he's (probably) safe

This is a non-answer with respect to Marack.

[Crackleslap]

@Firebert why are you so hellbent on lynching Lora but flip flopping like everyone else?

[Marack]

I lowkey don't like the bwon lynch. Even if she is scum, I kinda feel like its way to easy to just pile on the new player.

at what point in the game do you take benefit of the doubt away for a new player... who really hasnt offered any opinion and randomly followed other peoples votes without their own reasoning?

Many scum tells, even if they are low hanging fruit.

- - - Updated - - -

This is a non-answer with respect to Marack.

half assed attempt to not point any finger at me in hopes ill remove the vote

- - - Updated - - -

Marack said he's a human before so I think he's (probably) safe

We had someone claim to be vamp and was human... So what in my play makes you think im human?

[Crackleslap]

at what point in the game do you take benefit of the doubt away for a new player... who really hasnt offered any opinion and randomly followed other peoples votes without their own reasoning?

Many scum tells, even if they are low hanging fruit.

You're not wrong, but we're basically at a pivotal moment and we're basing the game on the new player looking scummy. Which is incredibly easy to do as a new player. (Make yourself look scummy regardless of alignment).

[Firebert]

@Firebert why are you so hellbent on lynching Lora but flip flopping like everyone else?

No-one else wants to lynch Lora and I don't want to end up like Marack.

[Crackleslap]

@Bwonsamdi the Dead If you think Graeham is potentially wolf/vamp, do you have any idea who their teammates might be?

[Marack]

You're not wrong, but we're basically at a pivotal moment and we're basing the game on the new player looking scummy. Which is incredibly easy to do as a new player. (Make yourself look scummy regardless of alignment).

i could go back and point all the issues where coaching looked like it happened between posts... or how wishy washy he's been... but i dont want to put for that effort.

Ive thought he was scummy and more so wolfy the last 2 days... but giving them time to play.

- - - Updated - - -

No-one else wants to lynch Lora and I don't want to end up like Marack.

what do you mean, end up like me? Sounds like inside info

[Firebert]

what do you mean, end up like me? Sounds like inside info

I mean, throw out a vote and then have it be completely pointless because there's not enough support for it.

[Graeham]

I'd argue that the players most likely to be human at this point are those who are examining the game from every possible angle. With that in mind, I definitely feel a lot better about Firebert.

- - - Updated - - -

I'd also question why Marack basically pieced together a bunch of names of who he found to be suspicious earlier on, yet somehow overlooked the guy most worthy of suspicion in the process. He claims to be suspicious of Firebert, too, though not enough to pay attention to the theories that Firebert has been engaging with which would have tipped Marack off to the fact that something wasn't right with Dupti before the guy outright admitted to being a vampire.