Can't wait to tell my future kids how many moderate Democrats complained about "defund the police being a bad slogan" and said Democrats shouldn't get on board with it because Republicans will attack them on it, right after the summer of the largest civil rights protest movement in American history. I want to make sure they learn a lesson about not becoming the white moderate that MLK warned us about decades ago.
They should change it to "Refund the Police."
It's accurate (reallocating funding) and everyone loves getting refunds.
Fuck that noise.
It's vague. All slogans are vague. That's the point of a slogan.
It's no less vague than MLK's "I have a dream". No less vague than "We shall overcome". Or "There's a change gonna come". Or "All Power To the People".
In fact, it's more specific. It specifies a target (the police), and a specific form of action (defunding).
This "it's a bad slogan" is just cover for willful ignorance and racist propagandizing with the intent of supporting and protecting police brutality. You have to pretend to not understand what "defund" means, or any of the context of the movement the slogan represents, and what they are asking for. To replace their position with whatever horse shit you have decided to lie and pretend is, instead, the intent.
What you mean is "the slogan is easy to lie about and misrepresent". And that's true of basically all slogans. By their nature, which is to be a brief inspirational (not descriptive or definitive) sentence fragment.
The real issue here is people playing into the disinformation campaign and accepting their horseshit manipulation as reasonable, and putting the blame for that on their targets. Fuck that. It's no different than the racist fearmongering about black power movements in the '60s, where this precisely the same tactic was used by white supremacist groups to misrepresent those in the civil rights movement. Same tactic, 60 years later, and we apparently haven't learned a fucking thing.
It's a fine slogan. If you don't understand what it means, it's because you choose to avoid making any effort to learn, because you are prejudiced against any support for black civil rights.
Note that the latter isn't directed at you. I'm sure you do understand it. You're just choosing to carry water for the racist disinformation agents professing that they don't, for some goddamned reason.
Last edited by Endus; 2020-11-12 at 05:01 AM.
Probably too early to say, but if Marco Rubio keeps talking like this he'll be a challenge in 2024. (Amusing to hear dems infighting)
As of Wednesday, 51 of Wisconsin's 72 counties had completed their canvasses. When you add up all of their totals, Biden gained 10 votes and President Trump lost 271 votes compared to the unofficial results from election night.
Not really a big deal considering the numbers are so small, but I thought this article - and the quote in particular - were funny.
It is also negative rather than positive
I like positive, goal oriented slogans personally, focusing on what is hoped to be gained not what is going to be lost
Of course to be perfectly fair.. if i lived in New York one glance at the NYPD might make me feel that defunding was the positive goal, i do not live in New York but rather Denmark where the positive goal would be repairing issues..
“Defund” has an inherently negative connotation to it.
::shrug::
"Auto-correct is my worst enema."