Mafia 138 - Game Thread - April Fools!

[LemonDemonGirl]

Sigh

Everytime I'm Town people think I'm Scum. Everytime I'm Scum, huh, same thing

[CerealLord]

Sigh

Everytime I'm Town people think I'm Scum. Everytime I'm Scum, huh, same thing

There is no way for anyone to know if you are town or scum. I just assume everyone is scum until they do things that make me think otherwise.

- - - Updated - - -

Well, except for scum. They know if you are scum or not. Lol

[Cruel2u]

@FoxxiMcLeod @Cruel2u

It might depend on the game mod too lol
I might have to have a look at my QTs later

(I'm not on my computer so it's hard for me to quote sorry)

Well you have to think worst case scenario, so in this case- 4 people would be able to confirm each other straight away, leaves 11 players unconfirmed, you lynch 1 player. You get an innocent and someone dies on night one, now in the worst case scenario Day two starts 13 players you need 7 to lynch and you already have 5 confirmed players. You mis-lynch and get another innocent. Day three opens with 11 players and 6 confirmed town. The game is over. That's just worst case scenario for town. Always good to do both town and scum.

[Clawsout]

unvote

Vote grae

Idk thats not very town of you to risk it

[Marack]

no because unlike marack im actually here and engaging

Hmm... so Grae wants to vote me even though in my 1 post (and 2 updates) I said what was going on and nobody was on for me to engage with...

Now keeping my vote there for trying to deflect the fact he was on the scum team that killed (N1) me on my birthday, and the desire to lynch me on the following game on D1

My trains by far the cutest

And you are on your own train

Omletting you get away with it!

I approve

- - - Updated - - -

also shame on you guys for outing the doc

[Graeham]

unvote

Vote grae

Idk thats not very town of you to risk it

Are you deflecting from a teammate?

Bwon's played a decent amount of games by this point. Enough to know that simply claiming to be a TPR when facing pressure and/or a lynch is enough to get even veteran players to immediately back off and look elsewhere.

If Bwon is scum, then there's almost certainly a veteran player on the scum team to coach her on the best way to cover up a slip. I daresay there could even be multiple veteran players.

[Clawsout]

Are you deflecting from a teammate?

Bwon's played a decent amount of games by this point. Enough to know that simply claiming to be a TPR when facing pressure and/or a lynch is enough to get even veteran players to immediately back off and look elsewhere.

If Bwon is scum, then there's almost certainly a veteran player on the scum team to coach her on the best way to cover up a slip. I daresay there could even be multiple veteran players.

No

Are you partners with xan and strikered? That sounds like a fun scum team to take apart

[Graeham]

In fact, here's a refresher of the player list, complete with 'veteran' players underlined:

Bwonsamdi the Dead
CerealLord
Clawsout
Crackleslap
Cruel2U
Foxximcleod
Graeham
Krayzy
Listo95
Lora
Marack
Rioriel
Strikered
Val the Moofia Boss
Xanjori

[CerealLord]

In fact, here's a refresher of the player list, complete with 'veteran' players underlined:

Bwonsamdi the Dead
CerealLord
Clawsout
Crackleslap
Cruel2U
Foxximcleod
Graeham
Krayzy
Listo95
Lora
Marack
Rioriel
Strikered
Val the Moofia Boss
Xanjori

Bwonsamdi started before I did and Claws like one game after me. If I am considered veteran, they should too :P

[Graeham]

Bwonsamdi started before I did and Claws like one game after me. If I am considered veteran, they should too :P

Bah. Fine.

Still, my point stands - aside from the player who has only just joined these games, pretty much everyone has a decent amount of experience under their belts.

[CerealLord]

Bah. Fine.

Still, my point stands - aside from the player who has only just joined these games, pretty much everyone has a decent amount of experience under their belts.

Your point is valid. Bwonsamdi could absolutely be coached and I already stated the players most likely to coach her and are active enough to be able to coach her immediately.

However, your comment about "we have another one" really rubs me the wrong way. You know you'd say the same thing if someone else said it too. You cannot deny that.

- - - Updated - - -
@FoxxiMcLeod @Xanjori

What do you guys think about Bwon's slip and then claim?

[Lora]

In fact, here's a refresher of the player list, complete with 'veteran' players underlined:

Bwonsamdi the Dead
CerealLord
Clawsout
Crackleslap
Cruel2U
Foxximcleod
Graeham
Krayzy
Listo95
Lora
Marack
Rioriel
Strikered
Val the Moofia Boss
Xanjori

this is entirely worthless.

[Clawsout]

In fact, here's a refresher of the player list, complete with 'veteran' players underlined:

Bwonsamdi the Dead
CerealLord
Clawsout
Crackleslap
Cruel2U
Foxximcleod
Graeham
Krayzy
Listo95
Lora
Marack
Rioriel
Strikered
Val the Moofia Boss
Xanjori

I like that you underlined yourself here lol

[Val the Moofia Boss]

pls help me bus my scumbuddy bwonsamdi so i can get more town points

[Crackleslap]

In fact, here's a refresher of the player list, complete with 'veteran' players underlined:

Bwonsamdi the Dead
CerealLord
Clawsout
Crackleslap
Cruel2U
Foxximcleod
Graeham
Krayzy
Listo95
Lora
Marack
Rioriel
Strikered
Val the Moofia Boss
Xanjori

....so you're saying if Bwons being coached by a veteran, we should lynch one the underline. So should we start with you?

Tbh i don't like the "bwon is being coached" story that gets thrown around when attempting to pressure/lynch her. Kinda feel like it's weak reasoning at this point. The decision has to be made whether believe the claim or not. Unless we get an obvious counter claim we shouldn't be lynching.

Unless the consensus is the thread wants to be really bold, and assume a lie has been told and lynch...suffer the consequences later.

[CerealLord]

....so you're saying if Bwons being coached by a veteran, we should lynch one the underline. So should we start with you?

Tbh i don't like the "bwon is being coached" story that gets thrown around when attempting to pressure/lynch her. Kinda feel like it's weak reasoning at this point. The decision has to be made whether believe the claim or not. Unless we get an obvious counter claim we shouldn't be lynching.

Unless the consensus is the thread wants to be really bold, and assume a lie has been told and lynch...suffer the consequences later.

I don't like it either, but it is going to happen at some point. All it needs is for Bwon to be on a team with people willing to do so and they will absolutely attempt to assist her.

Her response feels genuine enough to me that without a CC I'm not interested in lynching her.

[Clawsout]

Join me on grae guys its good times

[Cruel2u]

Well I don't think it was a slip. But then I thought Bwon was talking about what Foxxi and I had previously discussed about the mason groups. Hence Bwon tagged us both at the top of said message. Which makes me want to f.o.s everyone that jumped on immediately with out at least finding out what Bwon meant.

[LemonDemonGirl]

Bangs head against keyboard

Aaand here's the Coaching claim again...

[Lora]

doc claiming d1 is dumb. especially over so little push. gg town for outing the doc. basically just handing out free kills for mafia.