I don't understand how anyone with a functioning brain can even consider Blizzard putting together a team to create classic+ content. You know, the same company that did the bare minimum for all of classic so far, the same company that let bots and gold selling take over their game, the same company that changed batching about a day before classic ended... Yeah they are totally going to do it.
And look what a great game they are making with retail, everyone loves current Blizzard! They would totally create amazing content for classic!
Because making new original content for a version of a game that's over 16 years old just seems like a financial risk. It also makes no sense from a business perspective because the idea was to put in as little effort as possible and reap big profits. Blizzard didn't have to reinvent the wheel with classic, they just had to rerelease it and hope for the best. Blizzard has no intention to put effort into classic other than to make sure it's as bug free as possible. It's a nostalgia ride that has a definitive end. Also I'd prefer they focus on retail because that's the future of WoW, not a trip back in time to past expansions.
Most likely the wisest Enhancement Shaman.
Be that as it may, I would venture to say that really only Blizzard has the metrics and visibility to see whether or not it would be 'worth it'. You might be completely correct: it may in fact be something that would have little return on investment.
But, I think you also have to measure what that investment would actually be. Imagine if continued content wasn't anywhere near the scope of a traditional expansion. So no new massive game mechanics, no additional classes, no huge new zones to add in the game. What if the additions were smaller, more streamlined. New dungeons, raids and quests. Mostly reusing existing assets as much as possible. Instead of reinventing the wheel like they tend to do in an expansion, use a small dedicated team to continue building simpler content.
Now, only Blizzard really has the data to know how likely this could be profitable, but if they monetize it effectively, I do think that it could both bring in additional revenue, and also intrigue people into returning to a game that they don't care for (Retail) or feel like they've already done everything a million times (Classic).
I don't trust them to make new content that stays true to vanilla.
RIP Genn Greymane, Permabanned on 8.22.18
Your name will carry on through generations, and will never be forgotten.
Its not fixing any "mistakes", it's simply adding to the classic experience to give players who enjoy that era of the game more things to do.
It could be niche for all I care, but I'm quite certain many people would try it out if it contained new content.
- - - Updated - - -
Also, sometimes companies take losses in certain areas of the company to gain dividends in other areas. Even if it were to be a financial loss (which I don't think it would) to add more content to the classic era game, the amount of goodwill and positive player reactions would more than outweigh any perceived financial losses that the nay category posters think.
Blizzard: "Hey, we are doing seasonal classic era fresh servers!" "Also, we are creating a sub set of servers called classic+ with new content, more quests, raids, dungeons, activities!"
Players: "Fuck this, I hate blizzard, im mad! Why are they giving us new content?!!!?" /said no one ever.
No i don't think i would.
1. I still like retail wow despite the recent problems and have not given up hope, that the story will get back on its feet.
2. CLassic was a product of its time. They would have to change so much that the classic players would not like it anymore. Like for example making specs like moonkin viable. Becuase lets face it, classes in vanilla are no exactly... full of choice or any variables. Boring in the logn term.
3. You want them to deliebratly make bad graphics? If they make classic with modern artwork etc. and viable specs across the board... i guess i would be fine with it.
But no... making this would be Blizz saying everything they did after classic is shit. Which is not true. Even SL has it good sides.