Originally Posted by
Nzx
I'm not sure if this post is serious or not. It is honestly absurd to think that this game would even function with 52 different classes, let alone have 52 different classes with three substantially different specs, playstyles, roles, and balancing. Also, the list has Shadowhunter listed twice, but I can't be bothered working out if that's because there are 52 and you mistyped one or because there are 51, so I'm going to assume it's 52.
To have World of Warcraft with this many classes you'd lose unique class set bonuses because it'd be totally unrealistic to expect the level of gameplay altering tier bonuses we've had to be applied to 52 classes, 150+ specs. You'd lose unique class questlines, there's no way you could have unique class set designs, they'd have to remove racials or dilute them to the point of uselessness because it would be impossible to balance, even mundane shit like class colours wouldn't work properly because there aren't 52 immediately discernible colours. Imagine trying to run a pug 5-man and a Zandalari "Arcanitol" wanted to join. Would you expect the average player to understand the benefit spec 2 of the Arcanitol brings to their group, given that it's one of 150?
All of that, without even mentioning that there just aren't 150 different ways to play the video game. What makes the Arcanitol playstyle different to the Mage playstyle?
And then, if the only difference is cosmetic, how do you 1:1 translate every mage spell into an Arcanitol spell? How could you possibly have a "Fire Hydromancer", and what would their spells look like? If you manage to put that together, what does an Arcane Hydromancer look like, and if you manage to do that, what does a Frost Astromancer cast? And then how do you expect someone playing AV to understand what in the ever-loving fuck is going on when each team has 40 different individual classes that do the exact same thing except have totally different animations? Was the purple beam that just hit me a Witch Doctor heal or an Auchenai curse? Is that a Loa Priest or a feral druid?
Like, I 100% get that it would be really cool to see this kind of thing, the depth would be great, it'd be really fun if it all worked - but in reality, there's just no way that it would.