Originally Posted by
ravenmoon
I would never give elves shaman, but i wouuld give them a Moonguard class that uses the arcane to weave elemntal magic and control elementals, whether they do that in a respectful way as you would expect night elves and high elves, or would contorl them by h force as you may expect some blood elves, void elves or even night elven highborne to do..depends on the individual.
You are casting the same spells, but your class fantasy and means is differnet. A traditional shaman uses the power bestwoed on him by the elemntal to do the magic. Technically it's the elmental that is the power behind the manipulation, and his relationship with various elementals allows him to do so. He may bargain for this power (goblins), beseech respectfully this power (tauren), devote to the balance and harmony of the elemntals and so act as asort of mediator (orc) - but all the same the individual doesn't have magical power, i'ts the elmental he communes iwth that does and he learns how to use that elementals power throught he elemntal.
An elven Moonguard (placeholder name), however uses the arcane to generate elemntals, he doesn't need an elemental to gift him power or do things for him, through knoweldge of the arcane, elves learnt in the pre-sundering era how to create anything from it, fire, water/frost, earth, air and all things matter.. thea pplications were vast and an entire empire developed thanks to this knowledge with experts in all manner of fields. Whiles it's desturction left the surviving elf group atop Hyjal missing and losing so much, those hidden in cities like the Shen'dralar, Nightborne or those that remained Moonguard in Surmar, kept the knoweldge and arts unbroken. And their return in cata and Legion have basically opened them up to sharing with their elven kin, giving night elves and void elves on the alliance, blood elves and Nightborne the capability of being these elemental magicians.
They call elementals to aid them, not because they need their power to weave fire, earth, air or frost. - it really is the shaman mechanics, but it's a different class, different concept. The spells are very similar, they don't use totems, but arcane focuses attuned to certain elements to amplify the magic.. whereas traditional shamen use totems. They summon elementals too, like we know mages can do, and this special type of elemental mage is a master of it.
This si essentially the shaman class, but it has a different name on the elven races. One attuned to their lore and thier heritage.
The end result is that Elves don't get shaman, but they get a class that has the shaman play style. The elementalist. or call it the Moonguard. Elemental, Enhancement and Restoration. With restoration, instead of ancestral spirits, they employ Elune arcane healing techniques through water - a form of battle field magical triage they used in the absence of a a sisterhood of Elune, over the millennia, they gratly developed this into an arcane based form of healing that synergises with the light and water to heal., callin g on Elune