Naturalist is 250% larger than NSS/MSS. You are obsessing about a 5% difference in damage and come out with an example that is 150% off and call it comparable? Keep metaphors for your poetry, which I can only hope are better than your arguments.Naturalist was a random example of losing a comparable amount of DPS. If you don't understand what a metaphor is, then don't bother answering.
You think raiders having no off-spec is optimization? Do you even understand what optimization is?You call it small-minded dogmatism, I call it optimization. Granted, I don't expect you to agree, so it's merely a clarification. The main point asked by that poster has been solved, so this is the end of it.
Guilds where raiders have raid useful off-specs are better than guilds where no one has an off-spec at all. period. No amount of straw-man arguments or personal attacks changes that.