Originally Posted by
sofnr
I don't have an active raiding guild as I quit the raiding scene back in WoD, but I've had no issues pugging Heroic Uldir in its entirety every week. Yes, Zul hurts in P2 with the debuff if you take more than 2, but that goes for all tanks.
Tol'Dagor (first boss) is definitely annoying with necrotic, I agree with you there, but I've done it and it's not as bad as you make it (provided you have a competent group). I'm not sure why you think we have an issue with DPS, our DPS is phenomenal (on par or more than DH tanks I'd say in M+ during our burst). Also, you use Thunderclap to take aggro on AoE, I don't know what rage you need but generally speaking if the healer is anywhere near you it should be easy to pick them up.
I'm not saying prot warriors are fine compared to other tanks, but we're not as bad as you make us to be (in terms of DPS/Aggro). As far as the best tanks for MDI are concerned, this is also to do with utility. Mass Grip and the ability to self heal is so-damn important in M+ pushing, not to mention the other utility they have (res, cc, single grip, fear, stun, interrupts, knockbacks, enslave, good mobilty/snare, etc). Assuming we take the same damage or less than them and do very good DPS you'd still see primarily DKs or DHs just because of their utility. On some keys they can even have a healer DPS for the entire fight since they need no healing which makes things a lot easier in terms of some DPS checks.
Anyhow, my experience might not be as much as some other people here as I'm only reliant on pugging and I've done up to +12s without too many issues on my side (depends on the instance of course).